4 hours ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

Why Jabba?

I am inclined to vote for Mad because of his slip. I will not vote yet, there is plenty of time.

I have got reasons to vote for any of you. In Jabba's case:

He happened to be available for hammering and he didn't what is telling for either alignment, but telling still.

His behavior on D1, nothing in particular but his approach was radically opposed to CV's.

His vote on Mad. I'm not saying Mad is town, but the slip doesn't look like scum to me, and Jabba was ok with a L-1 in a moment I wouldn't for reasons I don't share.

He unvoted though.

5 hours ago, Matt3412 said:

10 hours left lets hear from everyone. so we can get coherent vote off before end of day.

Those that haven't voted/not currently have a vote out

@GhostofNobodyInParticular

@Madaghmire

@FortyInRed

@The Jabbawookie

5 hours ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

Why Jabba?

I am inclined to vote for Mad because of his slip. I will not vote yet, there is plenty of time.

I feel the same way as GNIP. We have time yet (it's approaching evening here, which is when I'm most available)

I was considering a vote for Matt, because I felt his last post was either town beginning to realize he’s hunting town, or scum who knows he’s hunting town laying groundwork to deflect. But his end of day 1 has me pretty convinced its the former.

I was concerned about ebon yesterday, but his vote on CV worked out so I’m in on town ebon for now.

Jabba pushed me to L-1 then unvoted. Could be town recognizing the validity of my point that hammering me early is bad townplay, and thats simply true regardless of what you believe my affiliation to be. Could be scum hoping an optimistic train for a quick town kill then seeing a chance after my post to build town cred by pulling off a player he knows will flip town but is likely to be killed anyway.

Ovi seems to be playing Ovi town.

Gnips and forty im neutral on thus far.

If we're sharing scum list I might share mine as well...

I'd like to go with Jabba but if Mad is the shot today I'm ok.

I'm gonna check the vote count.

I was worried about being at lylo tomorrow but I came out with what looks like as a relatively broken idea as we still have an investigation role.

I'm gonna fake claim weak doctor and I suggest everyone to do the same. Actually to fake claim is useless but funny.

The fact is that we might lynch someone, let's say Mad as it looks likely or even go with a no-lynch for better odds. Tonight I'm gonna visit Matt. Everyone must pick a name publicly and "visit" him. The left scum must headshot the doctor before the doctor visit him or stop killing and win through lynching us all.

In the morning, two deaths means we got him, one vanilla dead clear a suspect for the doctor, only doctor dead likely means we got him but also he might be lucky.

The system is not flawless but we get more info this way that waking up with a dead doctor not knowing who he visited.

##unvote Jabba

You're enough to lynch whoever you want without my help.

What you say? It's a plan?

**Visit Matt

I'm always skeptical of plans he enemy has perfect knowledge of

I guess it has a chance tho, now that I've read the weak doc role.

**visit fortyinred, if im alive

This is interesting.

I’ll visit Matt.

19 minutes ago, The Jabbawookie said:

This is interesting.

I’ll visit Matt.

Dude ovi already claimed him

1 minute ago, Madaghmire said:

Dude ovi already claimed him

My bad. I’ll take GNIPs, then.

I'll visit Jabba

44 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

I was worried about being at lylo tomorrow but I came out with what looks like as a relatively broken idea as we still have an investigation role.

I'm gonna fake claim weak doctor and I suggest everyone to do the same. Actually to fake claim is useless but funny.

The fact is that we might lynch someone, let's say Mad as it looks likely or even go with a no-lynch for better odds. Tonight I'm gonna visit Matt. Everyone must pick a name publicly and "visit" him. The left scum must headshot the doctor before the doctor visit him or stop killing and win through lynching us all.

In the morning, two deaths means we got him, one vanilla dead clear a suspect for the doctor, only doctor dead likely means we got him but also he might be lucky.

The system is not flawless but we get more info this way that waking up with a dead doctor not knowing who he visited.

##unvote Jabba

You're enough to lynch whoever you want without my help.

What you say? It's a plan?

**Visit Matt

So let's play this out. You are actually the doctor and you visit Matt.

If Matt is scum, you die.

If scum targets you, you die.

If scum targets Matt, you both survive.

So what's to stop someone from framing someone else?

Let's say tomorrow we wake up and you're dead. That'll point the finger at Matt, even if he's innocent, right?

13 minutes ago, FortyInRed said:

So let's play this out. You are actually the doctor and you visit Matt.

If Matt is scum, you die.

If scum targets you, you die.

If scum targets Matt, you both survive.

So what's to stop someone from framing someone else?

Let's say tomorrow we wake up and you're dead. That'll point the finger at Matt, even if he's innocent, right?

In order to frame Matt scum must kill me. If I flip doctor that's a pretty good shot from scum (given he doesn't really know me) and framing will last one day as best. If I flip vanilla Matt wasn't framed at all as it was obvious I was hunted down. Matt could be the scum though but at least the true doctor in that case reduced the pool of suspects.

45 minutes to go.

Gah decisions!

I'll leave the hammer to someone else. ##vote @Madaghmire

I'm willing to play for now

I will visit ebon.

@Bertie Wooster can we get an updated vote count

4 votes to hammer.

@The Jabbawookie (L-4)

@Madaghmire (L-1) (Matt, Ebon, Forty)

@GhostofNobodyInParticular (L-4)

@Matt3412 (L-4)

@ovinomanc3r (L-4)

@EbonHawk (L-4)

@FortyInRed (L-4)

This looks so scummy, but screw it.

##vote Madaghmire

That's hammer. Stop posting.

The fact that @Madaghmire didn't know all of the different crew assignments made the other crew suspicious. After all, who hasn't committed them to memory already?

After killing @Madaghmire with a harpoon, you realize he was just a Vanilla Town.

Night 2 begins. Have you seen any Purrgils yet?

@The Jabbawookie

@GhostofNobodyInParticular

@Matt3412

@ovinomanc3r

@EbonHawk

@FortyInRed

Day 3 begins, and @Matt3412 has been found slumped over a suura. Don't touch it, it's poisoned.

Matt was a Town 1-Shot Fruit Vendor.

@The Jabbawookie

@GhostofNobodyInParticular

@ovinomanc3r

@EbonHawk

@FortyInRed

Alright, I think it’s time to put my cards on the table.

I’m the weak doc.

Matt was town (protected N1 for fear of retaliation.)

GNIPs is town because I’m still here today.

I’m town because nobody’s going to counterclaim or they’re sealing their faction’s lynch-all-liars death warrant.

That leaves Ebon, Forty and Ovi. In light of Mad’s town flip I have chosen to trust Ovi and recommend hanging Forty and Ebon.

Getting us to this point was worth it in my eyes, especially given my shady play thus far. If someone has more info, now is probably the time, but given the setup I expect this is the best we’ll get.

##vote @FortyInRed Going back to old suspicions, bolstered by process of elimination.

Damm it, I could clear Matt cause he visited me, if you claimed and some else died instead it was done.

However it must be Forty or Ebon. Between Forty and Ebon I'd go with Ebon, mostly due to las day strategy.

Matt was obviously targeted by the remaining scum. I explained to Forty how framing wasn't a real option for scum so either he is bluffing like a boss (with no real effect) or he is town.

On the other hand Ebon was being visited by Matt himself. From his point of view, if Matt wasn't the doc he was "safe" and he could kill whoever he wanted. But if Matt was the doc and he killed someone else he was screwed. His only sure option was to kill Matt just in case he was doc.

##vote Ebon