So, last month I lost my home in a tornado. I was able to salvage my case that held Eldritch Horror and all expansions. Unfortunately, all of my monster tokens sat in a custom monster cup that was not able to be found. Is there a way to replace the tokens, or am I just going to have to buy everything over again? Eldritch is my favorite board game and I miss playing it so much.

On 5/19/2020 at 5:03 AM, normandy01 said:

Is there a way to replace the tokens, or am I just going to have to buy everything over again?

There are several ways. This was my first idea but the links aren't working.
You could even make proxies with a pen and paper, it all depends how good do you need them to look.
Which expansions do you have?

I'm so sorry that happened to you.

ANA/FFG aren't very friendly with replacement parts anymore. You could "check the box" and send them a quick email and explain the situation, but they'll probably just send their condolences and shrug.

Eldritch Horror Fandom has a complete list of all Monster and Epic Monster with all their information, just no photos.

https://eldritchhorrorgame.fandom.com/wiki/Monsters

Once you get to a point where you can, you might have to remake them.