3 minutes ago, markferguson said:Hello everyone. I’m back. I’d like to reiterate that I don’t like the message board because I forget about it for days at a time. However I am going to try and catch up on everything tonight.
I’m town by the way, just hate the messageboard
Welcome to the game @markferguson!!!
3 minutes ago, markferguson said:Can someone summarise the case against Cary for me?
I'm a cop, I investigated him, he is Scum
1 minute ago, markferguson said:Can someone summarise the case against Cary for me?
Clon revealed as a cop today, laid out his previous investigations, including Cary as scum. Before that we had evidence that two of this group (me, Ebon, Clon, Erik/Rewen, and Jessica C) were scum, given that Pod is now confirmed Fruit Vendor. The theory/plan is that we lynch Cary. If he's scum, proves Clon right, lynch one of the others from the group mentioned. If he's not, lynch Clon.
Is that about right folks?
1 minute ago, markdedrick said:Clon revealed as a cop today, laid out his previous investigations, including Cary as scum. Before that we had evidence that two of this group (me, Ebon, Clon, Erik/Rewen, and Jessica C) were scum, given that Pod is now confirmed Fruit Vendor. The theory/plan is that we lynch Cary. If he's scum, proves Clon right, lynch one of the others from the group mentioned. If he's not, lynch Clon.
Is that about right folks?
Correct
##unvote
we still have time to discuss
I want to hear from the people loging in before we lynch
9 minutes ago, markdedrick said:Clon revealed as a cop today, laid out his previous investigations, including Cary as scum. Before that we had evidence that two of this group (me, Ebon, Clon, Erik/Rewen, and Jessica C) were scum, given that Pod is now confirmed Fruit Vendor. The theory/plan is that we lynch Cary. If he's scum, proves Clon right, lynch one of the others from the group mentioned. If he's not, lynch Clon.
Is that about right folks?
well no, Clon has confirmed me as town.
So if Cary is scum it's out of you / jess/ rewen only
Evening all to UK folks, hello to all others. I’ve just caught up on the last ten pages and it strikes me that there is a very compelling case made against @CaryHaneyDC
i like the idea that we’ll get a better take on @clontroper5‘s cop claim one or way or the other by lynching Cary.
From my experience of playing with him he does always produce excellent spreadsheets which really help us in our investigations.
My take on @JessicaChase is that she’s playing a very similar game to the one I played in my very first game of Mafia when I was scum. So I’m minded to watch her as well.
I am prepared to lynch Cary now as I’m going to be of no use again all day tomorrow.
11 hours ago, clontroper5 said:So night one I investigated Wenchiman. Obviously I got a town result (which is why I targeted others day 2, but we really needed that Lynch so I joined the train anyway day 3)
Night 2 I investigated Ebon, Town result (wanted to confirm your sareph story) this confirms pod is protected
Night 3 I investigated caryhaneydc, Result, Scum. I was Quiet about it so far since I couldn't think of a good way to Target him without revealing I'm a cop. I now recommend lynching him (letting the Sensor do his thing) and come back tomorrow to the mafia vote issues. Hopefully with another set of information.
If I vote for Cary now does it take us to L2 or L1 or is it hammer?
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:well no, Clon has confirmed me as town.
So if Cary is scum it's out of you / jess/ rewen only
I stand corrected, this is right.
If clon is the cop and confirmed this is how tomorrow will look not accounting for night kills
@markdedrick: ? possible scum
@JessicaChase ? Possible scum
@Traingirl1 Town
@EbonHawk: Serph Knight - Confirmed
@clontroper5 Cop Town
@PodRacer Fruit Vendor - Confirmed
@Rewen007: ? possible scum
@Stefan Medium (sensor) town
@markferguson: town
@TheCallum Received fruit, town
Just now, Traingirl1 said:If I vote for Cary now does it take us to L2 or L1 or is it hammer?
L-2 i unvoted to allow you all to get in and talk
2 minutes ago, Traingirl1 said:Evening all to UK folks, hello to all others. I’ve just caught up on the last ten pages and it strikes me that there is a very compelling case made against @CaryHaneyDC
i like the idea that we’ll get a better take on @clontroper5‘s cop claim one or way or the other by lynching Cary.
From my experience of playing with him he does always produce excellent spreadsheets which really help us in our investigations.
My take on @JessicaChase is that she’s playing a very similar game to the one I played in my very first game of Mafia when I was scum. So I’m minded to watch her as well.
I am prepared to lynch Cary now as I’m going to be of no use again all day tomorrow.
If you would like, you can place your vote and then I will remove mine to allow for further conversation. Then Ebon and I can make sure he gets Hammered before the deadline
1 minute ago, EbonHawk said:@TheCallum Received fruit, town
Quick question about Callum's confirmation, does receiving fruit by itself confirm him as town? Or is there something else I missed?
If clon is confirmed, and cary is scum, we take Rewen tomorrow.
Then it's a toss-up between Jess and Mark
Just now, clontroper5 said:If you would like, you can place your vote and then I will remove mine to allow for further conversation. Then Ebon and I can make sure he gets Hammered before the deadline
yeah this makes sense we're the most active
Just now, markdedrick said:Quick question about Callum's confirmation, does receiving fruit by itself confirm him as town? Or is there something else I missed?
if cal is the cop and Cary is scum, callum is confirmed as scum can only be in you / rewen / jess as there will be only 2 scum left
1 minute ago, clontroper5 said:If you would like, you can place your vote and then I will remove mine to allow for further conversation. Then Ebon and I can make sure he gets Hammered before the deadline
Will do so now. Thanks.
##vote @CaryHaneyDC
##unvote
should be a comma between: confirmed, as
Just now, EbonHawk said:if cal is the cop and Cary is scum, callum is confirmed as scum can only be in you / rewen / jess as there will be only 2 scum left
Of course makes sense, we are assuming there are three scum, and Cary would be the one scum not voting to lynch yesterday. Got it.
22 minutes ago, markferguson said:Can someone summarise the case against Cary for me?
Clontroper5 claims to be a cop with a guilty on Cary