4 minutes ago, Rewen007 said:

By my count, the top quiet players are:

@CaryHaneyDC, @Wenchiman, @Traingirl1, @Madaghmire, @markferguson -- all in the 3-4 posts range and most of that was role confirm.

...seems odd for cary, wenchiman(adam), and markf based on Whatsapp Mafia play. Very odd. And 2 days of activity (given length of d2 is enough time to opt in...)

Following this is a second group of folks:

@JessicaChase, @thecallum, @stefan... (not sure why the names aren't linking) - all in the 7-8 posts range.

This helps as me/pod/clon/mad as we have no idea how you guys play, same for you with us I guess.. seems to be a consensus for your lot of those 4-5 though

and on the linking names it bugs out after so many if you copy reload and paste it allows to link again

52 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

Both active 2 hours ago, callum voted traingirl and she responded in kind to it... what makes you suspect them clon?

In the few games we’ve played Callum often starts with a vote against me!

4 minutes ago, Rewen007 said:

Question for @TheCallum, what led you to switch to this lynch vote from leaning towards @CaryHaneyDC 13 hours before this? Can you help us understand the logic here? Thanks.

that's what I want to know, it's the reason i voted him.. to call out someone and then drastically switch with no explanation is odd

2 minutes ago, Rewen007 said:

@Stefan, you've been active today (checking regularly), but not commenting. Any thoughts? Hypotheses?

Asking given I think you have family commitments, but from your earlier posts, you seemed to not want to play if the thread stayed quiet. Seems like that's changed now...

Thanks.

that could be scum not knowing how to enter the conversation a problem all scum have. As they know all the town due to already knowing all the scum it's hard for them to enter sometimes

4 minutes ago, Rewen007 said:

@Stefan, you've been active today (checking regularly), but not commenting.

Can you check this just by clicking the profile?

On 1/7/2019 at 8:29 PM, markdedrick said:

Can you check this just by clicking the profile?

hover over my name it will tell you if I'm online (green dot) or when i was last online and what I was viewing

that picture was meant to go into the salt thread on the main page, it's sneaked in here

And I've answered my own question. Shows @CaryHaneyDC hasn't checked in 7 hours, which is consistent with his often not being online during work.

this thread

my mistake

Now that I've learned this feature, we have several players who haven't even been on the site in more than 24 hours. Not sure if that should factor in or not? They're certainly not being helpful in these cases.

Just now, markdedrick said:

Now that I've learned this feature, we have several players who haven't even been on the site in more than 24 hours. Not sure if that should factor in or not? They're certainly not being helpful in these cases.

Yes and No:

General rule of thumb

Been offline all day - Odd behaviour

Been offline multiple days - Issue

I would put some on the odd behavior bracket, but mad in the last one.. he hasn't been online since friday which is very very odd...

Either way it's good to question the person, but innocent till guilty

Thanks, that makes sense. Things come up that can keep you offline for some time here and there.

my voting is just based on who is being the quietest, to try and either remove a non-player, or get more information for the town. There is no other explanation. Every time I've targeted someone they've come on and posted. That's information gain.

Am i still alive? Sorry I got lost in the baby vortex.

Nevermind im looking through and I appear to still be alive. Ok I’ll sort this out, can someone tell me when this day cycle ends?

2 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Am i still alive? Sorry I got lost in the baby vortex.

yes you are, I welcome your thoughts

13 minutes ago, TheCallum said:

my voting is just based on who is being the quietest, to try and either remove a non-player, or get more information for the town. There is no other explanation. Every time I've targeted someone they've come on and posted. That's information gain.

what're your thoughts based of this information gain then

4 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Nevermind im looking through and I appear to still be alive. Ok I’ll sort this out, can someone tell me when this day cycle ends?

@Lord Preyer

7 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Nevermind im looking through and I appear to still be alive. Ok I’ll sort this out, can someone tell me when this day cycle ends?

I believe we have approximately 18 more hours to go.

23 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

what're your thoughts based of this information gain then

Haha it’s all completely secondary to lynch votes. We need to get a few people on the noose.

6 minutes ago, TheCallum said:

Haha it’s all completely secondary to lynch votes. We need to get a few people on the noose.

No, it is not, that's an opinion. My vote is on you, and after that reply, it's staying on you.

You claim to vote people to get information, you then have no info to offer anyone, and encourage people to 'get on the noose' while doing absolutely nothing to give people reasons to get on it.
If you want people to lynch, offer a case or an argument, not nothing.

Pfft..

9 minutes ago, TheCallum said:

Haha it’s all completely secondary to lynch votes. We need to get a few people on the noose.

scum getting rumbled by chance

anyone want to talk? what do you think of callum?

1 hour ago, TheCallum said:

my voting is just based on who is being the quietest, to try and either remove a non-player, or get more information for the town. There is no other explanation. Every time I've targeted someone they've come on and posted. That's information gain.

42 minutes ago, TheCallum said:

Haha it’s all completely secondary to lynch votes. We need to get a few people on the noose.

this doesn't read town to me, ignores swathes of the game as well

I'm not sure what to make of him this game TBH.

16hrs 37mins

(Thanks to @markdedrick for clearing up my Marks mess up!)

@Traingirl1: can you please confirm whether you have or have not voted for @TheCallum? Thanks

VOTES:

 @Paulcrawford

 @CaryHaneyDC

  @markdedrick:

@JessicaChase

@Wenchiman: Rewen007 (L-6)

@Traingirl1

@Madaghmire:

  @EbonHawk:

@clontroper5

 @PodRacer

@Rewen007: Pod (L-6)

@Stefan

  @markferguson: Mark D.

@TheCallum: TrainGirl, EbonHawk (L-5)

   7 to Lynch.