8 hours ago, Kaiba6798 said:Things like DnD often times drastically change the system from edition to edition. Its why a lot of players adapted t he 3.5 instead of jumping from E3 to E4. and now they are on E5 and while many me chanics stayed the same there are a lot of differences.
That’s the thing; with D&D 4th, even with all its differences, I still felt a certain mechanical familiarity in the system. Though 4th was a radical departure in a lot of categories, I feel the degree of change between D&D 3.5 and D&D 4 is nowhere near the scale of the difference between AEG L5R and FFG L5R. FFG L5R claims a pedigree from the old game via Roll-and-keep, but my actual experience is that in practice the two systems don’t even feel the same. And that’s not to knock the new game mechanics, just that I feel like I’m playing a completely different game, not just a new edition.
I guess I’m just saying that I think it’d be okay for FFG to market this as a new L5R RPG rather than merely a new edition.
I also realize this is a very subjective differentiation.