Originally I put titles on the two Thugs but then I thought why? Is another 2 dice attack really worth giving up the turret on a modified (TL) dice attack? I don't think so...
In this list, you're probably right: you only have four ships, and one of them has (sometimes, anyway) just 2 Attack. You want to maximize the number of shots you get, and that means no A4 title.
In other lists, though, why not? For 23 points, Generic Y-wing + A4 + Ion Cannon Turret offers damage and control and a heavy, durable chassis. It requires flying with some finesse and good prediction, but that's a good thing for the game overall. On an individual basis they're certainly competitive with a Rookie Pilot or Blue Squadron Pilot, and worth a look for that reason
In other words, you can't just slap the A4 title on your current Y-wing build and be successful with it in the same way you've been successful in the past--but that second attack is a powerful incentive for people to find new ways to use it successfully.
For Scum maybe... but rebels will still get better use from the B-wing. Still for scum I expect the turreted effect will still be more desirable.
I'm not saying its bad, it actually seems balanced and it IS COOL. I'm just not expecting it to make a significant change in the meta, particularly in the long term. I think it'll end up being more of an aesthetic choice than anything else. However since I'm predicting player behavior, I'm not going to be very surprised (and it'd be a pleasant surprise) if I was wrong.
Of course it's still something that could be built upon with either new turrets or new pilots and I hope
FFG gives us more options that synergize well with this title.
...and we still don't know what that promise (probably the "Autothrusters" upgrade) FFG made to Interceptor players will mean for turrets.
All in all 2015 should be an interesting year.
Edited by Duty Remains