Editing is another of the skills that Lucas lacks
OT: Why wasn't Luke upset?
Editing is another of the skills that Lucas lacks
Wait...so he has some skills? Like what please enlighten me.
Editing is another of the skills that Lucas lacks
Wait...so he has some skills? Like what please enlighten me.
Pie eating.
Editing is another of the skills that Lucas lacks
Wait...so he has some skills? Like what please enlighten me.
Pie eating.
American pie?
He is good at taking other peoples ideas and putting them together....as long as he has supervision. And he pulls off the lumberjack look nicely *L*
I know a Monty python sketch that would work wonderfully if I could get the embed to work on my tablet.
You mean this?
Kinda OT but was it in one of the Republic Commando novels where it was some clones making fun of the Jedi saying if they really were so powerful they would have read the contingency orders and Order 66...
TCW season 6 covers this. No one but a few of the cloaners, Palp and Dokku knew about order 66.
I got the impression all of the orders were published in a manual or were part of the flash training routine the clones went under, and even so if they Jedi see Order 65 and Order 67 but they don't see an Order 66 in the Logs that should raise a few eyebrows
They were. All of the Clones knew about them. And some of the Jedi too. The Masters just didn't bother to. Yet another thing CW takes and twists out of recognition. 
They were. All of the Clones knew about them. And some of the Jedi too. The Masters just didn't bother to. Yet another thing CW takes and twists out of recognition.
Clone Wars is the canon source; if something else should conflict with that--say, a novel by an author who admits she has an ideological axe to grind against Jedi--then it's that secondary source that has it wrong.
They were. All of the Clones knew about them. And some of the Jedi too. The Masters just didn't bother to. Yet another thing CW takes and twists out of recognition.
Clone Wars is the canon source; if something else should conflict with that--say, a novel by an author who admits she has an ideological axe to grind against Jedi--then it's that secondary source that has it wrong.
Hmm...well it seems to me that that RepCom was made BEFORE Clone Wars decided to change everything. I couldn't care less about what Disney decides is canon or not. The EU is canon.
Hmm...well it seems to me that that RepCom was made BEFORE Clone Wars decided to change everything. I couldn't care less about what Disney decides is canon or not. The EU is canon.Clone Wars is the canon source; if something else should conflict with that--say, a novel by an author who admits she has an ideological axe to grind against Jedi--then it's that secondary source that has it wrong.They were. All of the Clones knew about them. And some of the Jedi too. The Masters just didn't bother to. Yet another thing CW takes and twists out of recognition.
It's probably best to think of the Republic Commando novels as Imperially supported, deliberately anti-Jedi propaganda dating from the beginning of the Emperor's New Order--in fact it's exactly the kind of thing he would have had done, in order to mislead people into believing that the Jedi were corrupt, contemptible, and irredeemable.
They may be enjoyable entertainment (very good propaganda often is), but they're inherently unreliable as a source of historical information.
Edited by Vorpal Sword
Even before the Disney purchase, Clone Wars took precedence over novels.
Hmm...well it seems to me that that RepCom was made BEFORE Clone Wars decided to change everything. I couldn't care less about what Disney decides is canon or not. The EU is canon.
Clone Wars is the canon source; if something else should conflict with that--say, a novel by an author who admits she has an ideological axe to grind against Jedi--then it's that secondary source that has it wrong.They were. All of the Clones knew about them. And some of the Jedi too. The Masters just didn't bother to. Yet another thing CW takes and twists out of recognition.
It's probably best to think of the Republic Commando novels as Imperially supported, deliberately anti-Jedi propaganda dating from the beginning of the Emperor's New Order--in fact it's exactly the kind of thing he would have had done, in order to mislead people into believing that the Jedi were corrupt, contemptible, and irredeemable.
They may be enjoyable entertainment (very good propaganda often is), but they're inherently unreliable as a source of historical information.
They're completely reliable. Basically what LucasFilm did was make CW, then realize it took canon and chopped it in half, and said 'Oh, we meant to do this the whole time. CW is canon even if it changes everything that was made before it.'.
Edited by tiefanatic