I've had BSG since it came out, and own both expansions (though I haven't experienced all of what Exodus has to offer).
Much of which the expansions add are optional rules, and the Pegasus expansion added two elements which I hated and won't be using again (the Cyclon Leader characters and New Caprica). Reading through the Exodus rules, I was struck with the thought of both expansions together would add an inordinate amount of stuff to the game, to the point where it would be borderline baffling and certainly not good for beginner characters.
So, are there any veteran players out there that believe they play the 'optimum' game, cherry picking elements from both expansions, dumping stuff that doesn't work so well, etc. And what are they?
Your thoughts are welcome.