I've played a game with one of my friends last Saturday. I performed a special attack with missiles against his Cova Nell who revealed his dial with a red maneuver. I claimed that his pilot ability does not work in this attack, and persuaded him to roll only 1 defend die.
I believed it was right but later on not only one of my other friends agreed that Cova Nell's pilot should work while defending special attacks. That makes me unconfident about my explanation.
Is it "While you ((defend) or (perform)) a primary attack, ...", or "While you (defend) or (perform a primary attack), ..."?
My friends all said that literally, if Cova's pilot ability does not work while defending against a special attack, there should be an "against" after the "defend" in the text - and that's the reason why my friends all said I was wrong - I understand the effect of the ability not from the text directly but from the translation, which may lead to my explanation.
And from a point of view, I just thought it was a mistake of wording for the designer to give 2 conditions that are so different to trigger a single effect.
We have a lot of abilities start with "While you defend or perform a primary attack," in the game, so its very important to make it clear how these abilities work.
So anyone could help to make it clear?
Edited by muzhyou