4 hours ago, Manchu said:Here again we must put matters into perspective. The Unicorn have been back for two hundred years. But their long absence created some territorial ambiguities. It is up to the diplomats to sort things out. After long negoatiation, the Ide and Ikoma emissaries worked out a deal to settle things between the Unicorn and Lion. The resulting alliance would have shored up the position of both Clans, at the very least by eliminating any disputes as to their common border. Outwardly, Shinjo Altansarnai accepted the hard work of her retainers. She made a treaty with the Lion Clan; she pledged her word on the honor of her name, the honor of her Clan, and her honor as the Unicorn Champion. This is the fundamental basis of diplomacy in Rokugan. As we know from Leadership , samurai are meant to keep their word. All that much more must this apply to Clan Champions managing the relations of the Great Clans.
But inwardly, her heart was unsettled. She wavered because of selfishness and pride. By reneging, she not only insulted the Lion Clan but also struck a blow at the basic constitution of Rokugan society. And so by her own irresponsibility she proved correct all those who look down on the Unicorn as wild, barbaric, and untrustworthy. This is the pain and scandal of Shinjo Shono, who is a true samurai. He is humiliated by the gaijin antics of his reckless mother. He understands that a real leader does not throw away the lives of uncounted retainers in a war to preserve one’s own personal desires. He was probably correct in surmising the Lion sent his own heart’s love against the Unicorn out of contempt. By living up to the tenants of Bushido, Shinjo Shono showed the Lion a striking counterexample to his mother’s lack of resolve. It would have been so much more preferable to have this excellent young man as a close ally but, since it cannot be the case, at least Lion samurai will have the honor of facing a virtuous and worthy opponent in the son if not in the mother.
Shinjo Shono’s example shows us that this is not some cultural difference between Lion and Unicorn. He expected better from his mother and is bitterly disappointed. The problem is therefore Shinjo Altansarnai. This is supported by the inference that the Ide diplomats, who must have known the whole situation as to the treaty if they are indeed capable of doing their jobs properly, did not explain to their Champion that the Ikoma daimyo was already married. This demonstrates that the Ide lack complete confidence in Altansarnai and Altansarnai’s actions in light of the revelation prove their skepticism is well grounded. I suspect that her lack of moral clarity, along with her audacious, schizoid decision to force the war her own previous policy sought to avoid, will prove a great temptation for an ambitious man like, say, Moto Chagatai.
All right I've been biting my tongue since I know many get annoyed by the back and forth that Manchu and I have on this topic and the habit it has of derailing threads but I can't let this once stand.
Since Manchu brought up Akodo's Leadership and the importance it put on Honor lets look at another quote from it.
“Samurai have no reason to be cruel. They do not need to prove their strength. A samurai is courteous even to his enemies. Without this outward show of respect, we are nothing more than animals. A samurai is not only respected for his strength in battle, but also by his dealings with other men. The true inner strength of a samurai becomes apparent during difficult times.”
Now lets look at the Lion/Unicorn deal in depth. The Lion are giving up an alliance with the Phoenix by having Ikoma Anakazu set aside his wife to marry Altansarnai, except they aren't since they had the arrangement that they just followed through on to have Toturi marry Keade. They are also offering not to attack the Unicorn over "disputed" lands. In exchange the Unicorn are having their Champion step down and accept the demotion from one of the 7 most powerful individuals in the Empire, that aren't part of the Imperial Family, to the wife of a Family Daimyo. They also ceded territory to the Lion as Hisu Mori Toride and the village that supports it and they "gifted" the Lion with a herd of Unicorn steeds. Lastly they agreed that the new Unicorn Champion would take a Matsu as his bride and thus his children and future heirs would be more closely tied to the Lion.
In every way I look at this deal it is great for the Lion as they are giving up nothing of value and gaining everything from it. Now the Unicorn on the other hand look to have taken a bad case of derp syndrome in the whole negotiation of this deal and that does make the whole Ide are great negotiators idea questionable (unless you accept the its a conspiracy to destabilize the Empire theory in which case it may have been negotiated like this just so that it would be so unpalatable that they Unicorn would have to renege on it and force this tipping point). But since its a "pre-story" point and the idea that the failure of the negotiations is necessary to set up our narrative going forward, similar to the whole Yoshi can't seem to diplomat his way out a wet bag (#kakitayoshiisafool), we have to accept that something went wrong.
The norm in any Rokugani marriage is that the lower ranked party would take the name of the higher ranked individual, so Clan Champion should trump family Daimyo, and we should assume that would be the default that the Ide were working from in this arrangement. However the Ikoma seem to have an "obscure tradition" which says that no Ikoma male ever takes the name of his wife regardless of the difference in their ranks (funny though how they didn't care about the Matsu tradition which is that Matsu brides don't give up their family name or position when they offered Mitsuko as a bride). The fact that Anakazu was already married is also an open question mark as yes it is likely something that should have been generally known to the Unicorn.
Now if the Lion were living up to the tenet of Courtesy and the idea that one should avoid unnecessary cruelty you would think they would have mentioned this obscure tradition that they planned to enforce in their negotiations instead of letting it be a surprise rider after everything was agreed, but all evidence we have from the fiction is that it was not mentioned at anytime until after the negotiations were concluded and they apparently said right so when are you abdicating and moving in with Anakazu.
We should note that Altansarnai was willing to swallow her pride and accept that insult that the Lion were forcing on her in this negotiation, she was going to sacrifice the happiness that she had with Iuchi Daiyu for the good of her family despite the urging of many of her advisers (including Kamoko who as a Battle Maiden is one of the Unicorn who has come to most closely accept the tenants of Bushido we are told) and it is only when she is confronted with the collateral cruelty to those outside of her immediate circle (Anazaku's wife who saw no choice but to commit ritual suicide to protest the wedding) that she finally decided she could not follow through with the marriage. Her response was to do as all good Samurai should and send a messenger to the Emperor to notify him of her intent and accept what ever punishment he may deem appropriate for her breaking the treaty.
The Lion response on learning this was to attack Unicorn holdings and seize them (without Imperial Permission) and when the Unicorn retaliated to claim it as proof of their aggression against them to force the Emperor to authorize them to march to war against the Unicorn. Again its funny how when the Crane seized Toshi Ranbo (a Lion holding) and the Lion counter attacked to reclaim their city they were the ones in the right as they were just "defending" their territory from the aggression of another clan.
Claiming that Shono is a paragon of virtue and that he is "disgusted" by his mothers actions is taking things a little to far as what we've actually seen in fiction is that he disagrees with his mother not because he sees her as having dishonored herself and her clan but rather that he doesn't want to antagonize his neighbors and while he is torn as to his love for Mitsuko versus his duty to protect his clan when his mother gives and order he is quick to follow as is the duty of any true Samurai. Saying that Unicorn are "forcing" this war when the Lion at each step appear to have been manipulating matters and are frankly acting in the role of antagonist is some pretty blatant victim blaming.
Edited by Schmooziestypo