7 hours ago, jagsba said:

All ******* cursing is God **** necessary as ****

Profanity is a minor warning and “spouting unnecessary profanities” is a major warning. So clearly there’s difference. I can’t wait to get the next Illuminati release.

1 hour ago, skotothalamos said:

Profanity is a minor warning and “spouting unnecessary profanities” is a major warning. So clearly there’s difference. I can’t wait to get the next Illuminati release.

They came for the turrets, and now they nerf the tourettes!

Missing anything?

Extended Meta:

Scum

• Ketsu+
• Boba+
• Cartel of Legend
• Some token sharing IG88A List
• Control Beef

Empire

• Trip Ace List closer to or at 200
• Palp Aces
• Phantoms Re-Vengeance
• Sloane Swarm or Sloane Aces
• Squad of Legend Revival

First Order

• Kylo Tavson+
• QD+ Multiple Things
• Kylo QD Midnight

Republic

• Anakin+ 2-3
• Obi + Mace/Ric + Things
• Sinker Beef

Rebel

• Biggs Beef
• AP5 Beef
• VCX+ Things
• Han/Lando+ Things
• Wookie Place Holder

Resistance

• Nodin + Korr + R4
• Rey + Korr + Title
• AAAA Tide Pod
• European Vennie
• Bad Quad T70 Lists
• Trench Run Attempts

CIS

• Literally doesn't matter
• TA175 & Hyena Stuff

Misc

• Bomb List Place Holder

23 hours ago, jagsba said:

All ******* cursing is God **** necessary as ****

I agree

16 hours ago, skotothalamos said:

Profanity is a minor warning and “spouting unnecessary profanities” is a major warning. So clearly there’s difference. I can’t wait to get the next Illuminati release.

In the year 2063, mankind lingers on destruction. Xwing seventh edition launches. Additionally, the community judges finally put out an answer for how Sunny Bounder, rebel Han, and dooku interacted in second edition.

45 minutes ago, Brunas said:

Sunny Bounder

What’s confusing about Sunny now? Aside from people like me using her despite that she’s pretty bad

5 hours ago, Boom Owl said:

Resistance

Still think 5A is a thing. I just went 4-2 with it in Paris today, so a better player should make cut. And there are enough around who demonstrate this repeatedly.

3 minutes ago, GreenDragoon said:

Still think 5A is a thing. I just went 4-2 with it in Paris today, so a better player should make cut. And there are enough around who demonstrate this repeatedly.

1 hour ago, LagJanson said:

What’s confusing about Sunny now? Aside from people like me using her despite that she’s pretty bad

If I dooku your roll, do you add sunny dice before or after dooku happens?

12 minutes ago, GreenDragoon said:

Still think 5A is a thing. I just went 4-2 with it in Paris today, so a better player should make cut. And there are enough around who demonstrate this repeatedly.

was that the "no Wave 4" System Open?

4 minutes ago, skotothalamos said:

was that the "no Wave 4" System Open?

Yep. More Decimators, a ton of Jedi, and a lot people copying our swiss guy with the UUUU (including another swiss guy who made cut).

As for the "no wave 4"... I don't know, I still don't see the new broken OP stuff in there. An N1 is not that different from another Jedi in terms of your approach. And resistance hasn't found it yet I think?

5 minutes ago, Brunas said:

If I dooku your roll, do you add sunny dice before or after dooku happens?

🤨 After (so in effect Sunny wouldn't be able to add a die since for Dooku to work the results she rolled would have to be different from the result he chose). You mod your own dice second.

15 minutes ago, Hiemfire said:

🤨 After (so in effect Sunny wouldn't be able to add a die since for Dooku to work the results she rolled would have to be different from the result he chose). You mod your own dice second.

You got to the right answer (probably) but uhh, not for the right reasons. The answer is actually different based on when we're even asking the question.

Sunny (before the Han FAQ) was added before dice mods - after the Han FAQ, it's now during the standard mod step. Dooku actually isn't an opponent dice mod. He's not really an anything. Dooku tells you that you have to modify your own dice. What dice mod step does it happen in? There isn't a right answer, by the way.

10 minutes ago, Brunas said:

You got to the right answer (probably) but uhh, not for the right reasons. The answer is actually different based on when we're even asking the question.

Sunny (before the Han FAQ) was added before dice mods - after the Han FAQ, it's now during the standard mod step. Dooku actually isn't an opponent dice mod. He's not really an anything. Dooku tells you that you have to modify your own dice. What dice mod step does it happen in? There isn't a right answer, by the way.

He pays the cost before the dice are rolled (per the wording on his ability) and the rest of his ability is applied at the normal timing. The Attack portion of the RR specifies "abilities".

2. Attack Dice: During this step, the attacking player rolls attack dice and the players can modify the dice.
   1. Roll Attack Dice: The attacking player determines the number of attack dice to roll based on the chosen weapon's attack value, range bonus, and any abilities that add or remove attack dice. Then they roll that many dice.
   2. Modify Attack Dice: The players resolve abilities that modify the attack dice. The defending player resolves their abilities first, then the attacking player resolves their abilities.

3. Defense Dice: During this step, the defending player rolls a number of defense dice equal to the ship's agility value and the players can modify the dice.
   1. Roll Defense Dice: The defending player determines a number of defense dice to roll based on the defender's agility value, any range bonus, whether the attack being obstructed by an obstacle, and any abilities that increase or decrease the number of defense dice. Then they roll that many dice.
   2. Modify Defense Dice: The players resolve abilities that modify the defense dice. The attacking player resolves their abilities first, then the defending player resolves their abilities.

1 minute ago, Hiemfire said:

He pays the cost before the dice are rolled and the rest of his ability is applied at the normal timing. The Attack portion of the RR specifies "abilities".

2. Attack Dice: During this step, the attacking player rolls attack dice and the players can modify the dice.
   1. Roll Attack Dice: The attacking player determines the number of attack dice to roll based on the chosen weapon's attack value, range bonus, and any abilities that add or remove attack dice. Then they roll that many dice.
   2. Modify Attack Dice: The players resolve abilities that modify the attack dice. The defending player resolves their abilities first, then the attacking player resolves their abilities.

3. Defense Dice: During this step, the defending player rolls a number of defense dice equal to the ship's agility value and the players can modify the dice.
   1. Roll Defense Dice: The defending player determines a number of defense dice to roll based on the defender's agility value, any range bonus, whether the attack being obstructed by an obstacle, and any abilities that increase or decrease the number of defense dice. Then they roll that many dice.
   2. Modify Defense Dice: The players resolve abilities that modify the defense dice. The attacking player resolves their abilities first, then the defending player resolves their abilities.

Right, but you've missed the point. "the ship must change 1 die" - who's mod step does that happen in? Why? There's not a correct answer, by the way.

6 minutes ago, Brunas said:

Right, but you've missed the point. "the ship must change 1 die" - who's mod step does that happen in? Why? There's not a correct answer, by the way.

You're over complicating the interaction. His ability would be applied before Sunny could apply hers because it is his ability that is causing the modification.

17 minutes ago, Hiemfire said:

You're over complicating the interaction. His ability would be applied before Sunny could apply hers because it is his ability that is causing the modification.

That's definitely a reasonable way to handle it, but we have no guidance from the rules in any way that it's the correct way. Treating it as a step that must happen in the dice modification step of the ship dooku is effecting is equally valid. Doing it before anyone does anything (before the opponent modify dice step) is also reasonable, though I'm not sure if that meaningfully differs from doing it during the opponent's modify dice step.

If you'd prefer though, because this one is so obvious, I can just change my hypothetical to how which happens first when you're using lando crew - Han's pilot ability, or and opponent's dooku crew?

42 minutes ago, Brunas said:

If you'd prefer though, because this one is so obvious, I can just change my hypothetical to how which happens first when you're using lando crew - Han's pilot ability, or and opponent's dooku crew?

In player order per the rules on Ability Queue...

4 minutes ago, Hiemfire said:

In player order per the rules on Ability Queue...

You're assuming they have the same timing window (which I think is a reasonable assumption), but again I couldn't fault someone for disagreeing.

Here, I'll edit my joke even further: "rules pending answering by community judge group is answered"

yay, now no one can tell people with questions their questions are stupid

4 minutes ago, Brunas said:

yay, now no one can tell people with questions their questions are stupid

Can I call them stupid instead?

3 hours ago, Boom Owl said:

I suspect, for the purposes of a pod in place of an A-Wing in 5A, this is a case of "new stuff" wishful thinking.

3 hours ago, Boom Owl said:

French meta according to Boomowl:

"Now THIS is podracing! Hon hon hon hon oui oui baguette du fromaige!"

9 minutes ago, gennataos said:

I suspect, for the purposes of a pod in place of an A-Wing in 5A, this is a case of "new stuff" wishful thinking.

Yea I dont have any table time with it to know if its ok or not. Just assuming a decent # of Resistance players are going to fight for Poe's card at grand champs and will take familiar things.

2 minutes ago, player3010587 said:

French meta according to Boomowl:

"Now THIS is podracing! Han han han han oui oui baguette du fromaige!"

Ftfy