Can the Genie take the spells cast by the Genie from the discard pile

By ChadtheDragonLord, in Talisman Rules Questions

Can the Genie take the spells cast by the Genie from the discard pile?

Nope, sorry.

"...treat the Spells as though you had cast them"

So when you cast Spell Call* for example the spell will be given back to you.

Cheers

Oops I meant to say Gypsy - Can the Gypsy take the spells that the Genie cast and placed on the discard pile (The Genie is owned by another player.)

Edited by ChadtheDragonLord

Hehehehe just to say is that the Genie follower or the Jin Blooded or even the Genie Nomad made characters?

Oops I meant to say Gypsy - Can the Gypsy take the spells that the Genie cast and placed on the discard pile (The Genie is owned by another player.)

I think NO.

Prophetess cannot see Spells of Genie.

For the same reason Gypsy cannot take a Spell. In fact, YOU DON'T discard the spell.

"The Genie will cast the Spells whenever you wish ( treat the Spells as though you had cast them )." This part is a reference to the effect of the spell. When the Spell applies, the discarded spell is no more the character' spell.

This is not your spell, so you don't discard the spell. The spell is just discarded (by the Genie).