OK, here is a question that came up the other day concerning that old Hastur favourite, Pulp Writer from the Forgotten Cities set. It has two printed terror icons and the text: “Action: pay 1 to choose a character with fewer terror icons than Pulp Writer. That character loses a terror icon, then goes insane, if able.”
It’s the “if able” bit that is confusing me. According to the FAQ: “Certain card effects contain the text ‘if able.’ For these cards all normal rules apply for choosing targets and triggering effects, with one exception: if there is no legal target during resolution, there is no effect.” It goes on to say “if a player cannot fulfil the entire effect of an ‘if able’ clause, that effect is ignored.”
My question is this then: can Pulp Writer send a character with no terror icons insane? I had always assumed he could, but I am now having second thoughts. Does the ‘if able’ clause mean that the target must have at least one terror icon to remove (because the wording says it loses a terror icon), otherwise the whole effect will fizzle?