Etahn is solid.
HLC Defenders are pretty tough too, as they can take quite a bit of ***** to kill with a 3 dice gun, especially at Range 3.
Without Rebel Captive, Phantoms are tough. Predator and Gunner can only get you so far.
Multiple B Wings is tough, since your squad choices leave you with minimal guns to take on all that hull and firepower.
Ion Control is pretty annoying.
As always, stress mechanics make it tough if you run PTL.
As a way to counter the Decimator's counters, the Phantom is pretty great to beat out the Swarm threat. However, the Phantom is mighty weak to Rebel Captive and other stress mechanics. Also, Ions arent bad at beating Phantoms. In general, id guess the Phantom + Decimator list's biggest weakness would be some Rebel Ion or Stress control list. Mirror matches become interesting, as any Decimator with Rebel Captive is almost unshootable by the Phantom.
I haven't yet seen a etahn or defender list that doesnt die to everything else in the mat though. so, im a little less worried about that. can someone show me a list?
Now, a Z packing some IPMissiles looks like it might be bad. stressors also still bad.
I agree about Etahn and Defender. However, with new ships and new meta, I DO expect to see some other ships come out to play more. I'd say Vessery + VI + Engine + HLC certainly has a place in this meta, Rexlar as well, heck, maybe Rexlar more if I can find support I like (some reason those 2 more pts just put Rex into a weird position). PS 8 and HLC for Dash, HLC gun or anti Phantom support for Phantoms. At least, I EXPECT to see them at least once a tourney, instead of 0 times each tourney. Defender + Decimator will see some love, for those that don't like Phantoms all that much.