I know that I have not played too many scenarios in the LOTR game, but I just had what I feel was my best result yet.
Passage Through Mirkwood.
As an aside I just received my 2nd core set this Christmas. So, what I own is 2 core sets and both Hobbit saga expansions. And I only used core cards in these decks.
I played 2 handed in this scenario. Tactics/Lore & Spirit/Leadership. My heroes were Legolas, Gimli and Beravor & Aragorn, Theodred, and Eowyn.
I managed to beat the scenario in 5 turns. And that included ending up with the Don't Leave the Path segment. I did my first point add up and came up with 70 points. No one died. and there were only 3 damage tokens on my heroes at the end. I had all of the cards in the deck. No easy mode. And I used the Shadow cards. Previously, I had only played easy mode and with no shadow cards.
In this short amount of time, I managed to have in play all 3 Stewards of Gondor (they really will let anyone be Steward), Aragorn had his Celebrian's Stone, Gimli had his dwarven axe, and I had 2 Northern Trackers in play. I swear I did not stack the decks. My tactics/Lore deck even had 3 Gandalfs in hand.
I feel that I could not possibly have another game go as well as this one did.