My third time playing, the top left wing fell of my X-wing model. Nothing was handled rough, but stuff happens, right? I'm not super familiar with miniature models, is there a preferred method for gluing that back on? Any recommended products / procedures?

I had a gun come off an X-Wing. I use super glue and an old paint brush to put it back together.

If you post a picture of how the break looks i'm sure some of the better Modelers will have better tips for you depending on the break.

I've used Ambroid Pro Weld for all of my plastic gluing needs, in fact I just used this to fix the broken mount for one of my X-wings

http://www.amazon.com/Ambroid-110-Pro-Weld/dp/B0035Y26HS

Superglue works well. But I'd recommend getting some plastic model glue and use that. It should give you a better bond. I've used it because the sleeve you put the post into broke off on one of my X-Wings and a Tie Fighter.

Zap-a-gap.. it's awesome...