Would this be acceptable?

By SpectreSix, in X-Wing

There's some threads about the TIE Defender wanting to be in the game, and I thought forever what the Rebel counterpart would be, and here it is: The E-wing. As some of you might know. the E-wing was a fighter introduced during the fighting with Thrawn and his fallen Empire, and then most famously later during the Battle of Mon Calamari against the World Devastators and cloned Palpatine in the Expanded Universe.

I know, I know... That dreaded phrase. But stick with me. The E-wing should have these stats in my opinion. * = The E-wing carried 16 torpedoes. **= the E-wings were equipped with Ion Cannons during the Mon Calamari battle.

Attack Dice: 3

Defense Dice: 2

Hull: 3

Shields: 3

Focus, Target Lock, Barrel Roll, Evade

Astromech, Torpedo, Torpedo*, (Cannon?**)

Pilots:

  • Knave Leader
  • Knave Three
  • Blackmoon Squadron Pilot
  • White Team Pilot

As for the TIE Defender, since I am a player for both sides, here's what I think it should be.

Attack Dice: 3

Defense Dice: 2

Hull: 4

Shields: 3

Focus, Barrel Roll, Evade

Torpedo, Missile, Cannon

Pilots:

  • Maarek Stele (there's a reason for this)
  • Rexler Brath
  • Onyx Squadron Pilot

The TIE Defender was a really strong fighter in the TIE Fighter PC game. It was equipped with ion cannons and could hold torpedoes or missiles. More maneuverable than I originally thought, but able to take more hits than a TIE Interceptor. I made the defense dice 2 because if it was 3, it'd just be a glorified TIE Interceptor with X-wing shields.

Now the reason for the Maarek Stele pilot is because he not only flew a TIE Advanced, but he also flew a TIE Defender. Now I'm not saying he should have a pilot card for every TIE ship in the game (even though *cough cough* a TIE Bomber would be great), but he was too important to the TIE Defender's success to forget. It's the same as if they forgot Wedge and Luke's importance to the Rebellion's X-wing.

E-Wing wise. Yeah would go with Cannon, also I think System Upgrade as they were a much more advanced fighter than the X-Wing.

Torpedo, Torpedo*, Astromech, Cannon, System Upgrade

The Defender should really have Agility 3 it is very maneuverable. Hull-wise it was better than the Tie, but not by an awful lot (it still had the delicate panels) So I prefer Hull 3... It also needs Target Lock or it just can't use it's missiles.

My feeling is

Attack Dice: 3

Defense Dice: 3

Hull: 3

Shields: 3

TL, Focus, Barrel Roll, Boost

Missile, Cannon, System Upgrade

(I know they could take Torpedoes, but they have a very low load compared with other ships and taking both would seem a bit much as the X-Wing could take half as much again as the Defender but only gets a single ordnance slot)

A-Wing dial.

Edited by Rodent Mastermind

E-Wing wise. Yeah would go with Cannon, also I think System Upgrade as they were a much more advanced fighter than the X-Wing.

Torpedo, Torpedo*, Astromech, Cannon, System Upgrade

The Defender should really have Agility 3 it is very maneuverable. Hull-wise it was better than the Tie, but not by an awful lot (it still had the delicate panels) So I prefer Hull 3... It also needs Target Lock or it just can't use it's missiles.

My feeling is

Attack Dice: 3

Defense Dice: 3

Hull: 3

Shields: 3

TL, Focus, Barrel Roll, Boost

Missile, Cannon, System Upgrade

(I know they could take Torpedoes, but they have a very low load compared with other ships and taking both would seem a bit much as the X-Wing could take half as much again as the Defender but only gets a single ordnance slot)

A-Wing dial.

Good point with the Target Lock. That slipped my mind.

The nerfed version of the TIE Defender (post TIE-Fighter game) would be 3/3/3/4, or 3/2/3/4, so pretty close to what you have. Just swap hull and shield values: it needs 4 shields, as it had 100 SBD after it got nerfed.

The original TIE Fighter version (pre-nerf) would be 3/3/3/8, and with a dial that would make the A-wing look like a Y-wing by comparison.

Edit: also consider the system upgrade on the ship. You could install everything and the kitchen sink on this thing, it was very versatile.

Edited by MajorJuggler