I think it's kind of funny that once or twice, this thread mentions lack of Jedi as a positive thing. Different genres, but Jedi = Samurai = Gunslinger. Less so in the Prequel era, but the idea of a lone weapon master dispensing justice from town to town/world to world...
An iconic samurai or gunslinger doesn't require magical powers. An iconic Jedi pretty much does. You can make a *heck* of a gunslinger or 'samurai' without ever referencing the Force rules. The Jedi may originally have been (loosely) modeled on samurai, but they went well beyond that archetype.
I respectfully disagree. It's all about perspective and context. With a traditional samurai move or spaghetti Western, the samurai or gunslinger is just as far head-and-shoulders in power level above "normals" as a Jedi. A gunslinger or samurai DOES, in fact, have "magical powers" (although they are usually related solely to their supernatural combat expertise and possibly intuition rather than the ability to move things with their minds). Ultimately, though, same character, different weapons.
BTW, the Dark Times comic book did a great story arc called Blue Harvest, which is based on the Yojimbo/Fist Full of Dollars model and stars Das Jennir, a Jedi. Fantastic story, and an overall really, really good comic. Anyone who doubts that Jedi belong in the EotE should check out Dark Times.
Blue Harvest. Last Man Standing. Fist Full of Dollars. Yojimbo. The works of Dashiell Hammett (Red Harvest and The Glass Key). Same hero, different weapons.