So for those of you who don't spam re-fresh the AGOT news page in the hopes of an FAQ, the new article " Truths found in the Fires " gives us a new FAQ and new Tourney Rules .
The biggest changes are the errata to The Long Voyage (Neutral House Only) and the change to Melee scoring for tournaments... The article states that the goal was a lighter-handed "minimalist" approach to the restricted list, and I think it's succeeded; with a few additions they've blown the meta wide-open again, without us having to completely rebuild all of our decks. Given that we're only 3 weeks from Gencon, I think that's wise!
The melee changes, aside from some additions to the RL (Corpse lake and Art of Seduction really surprised me, although it has me scratching my head for some obvious collusion-AoS play I haven't yet thought of). The new melee scoring, where you score 15 points for winning and your power divided by your placing for 2nd-4th place, incentivizes winning in what I suspect is a bid to decrease the reward for "playing for second". It's the game of thrones... you win, or you get almost no point - seems thematic. Edit: It seems the points example for melee mistakenly awards Glen 3 points instead of 2.
Now, a few weeks back I made an FAQ wishlist for additions other than the restricted list. People posted some of the biggest rules questions they had and would like to see addressed and, to my delight, almost all of them were addressed. They clarified the timing on Rhoynar emissary, they fixed typos in Battle for Shield Islands and Rhoynar emissary, fixed some templating with the No-Agenda Martell knights, and clarified some important timing issues (that especially affect Call of the Three-eyed Crow), as well as Shadows (Edit: The timing charts refer to bringing cards out of "Shadow", not "Shadows"). They even forestalled some questions I hadn't thought of; running multiple +1 STR wildling agendas, for instance!
There are a few items on that list I'm sorry to see missed the FAQ; typos like Randyll/Randyl Tarly, Jhalabar/howeverit'sspelled and Margaery (her text misspells her name). Given that some of the other ones posted have since been answered, I thought I'd add them here:
- Clarify the Dreadfort/Sons of Mist scenario ( Answered by Ktom here )
- Clarify the Much and More (Revealing Cards 1 at a time like draw? Does it apply to discard-from-deck effects?) ( Answered by Damon here )
- Clarify the null value (Do I still shuffle my deck if 0 cards "remain" on Summer Sea Corsair?)
- Clarify the timing on Naval superiority with Naval characters being removed from challenges. ( Answered by Ktom here )
So - what does everyone else think? Any obvious ruling missed? Any house the obvious winner from the restricted list or the new melee scoring? How much did you chuckle on seeing TLV's errata?
Edited by -Istaril