Came up on BGG and I'm curious if this board comes to a different conclusion.

I have two dead Theon Greyjoys (the one that discards to come back into play).

Do I...

trigger his ability twice and put both back into play, one as a dupe and one as a character?

OR

trigger his ability twice, but never put either into play as one is always in the dead pile?

In my opinion, because each Response is triggered separately, there is no chance for either to be put into play because the other copy is still in the dead pile at the time each Response would be triggered.

and how are there two in the dead pile?

Viseny's Hill and Aegon's Hill are two popular ways.

Since you already know there's an FAQ entry directly on point, what was the purpose of posting this question?

Since you already know there's an FAQ entry directly on point, what was the purpose of posting this question?

game. set. match.

~Oh no he didn't!

Since you already know there's an FAQ entry directly on point, what was the purpose of posting this question?

Because I don't remember random one-off stuff like that all that well.