Sorry if I missed this earlier somewhere:
In this situation Player A is attacking Player B. Player A wins. Player B then casts random on Player A, apparently before Player A has taken his reward (life/object/gold).
Someone made the argument that you cant interrupt the 'space in time' between winning combat and gaining the reward…this same argument came up again like this:
Player A holds the Rod of Ruin . (The one that can remove up to two str/cft points from anyone, apparently at will, although the item does not state specifically when it can or cant be used). Player A attacks Player B. Player A looses, though upon realizing that the defender will likely take the Rod as a reward and use it it against them, Player A hastily uses the rod before Player B can claim it as a reward.
Legal? Is there a official combat sequence?