Throwing Spear is a very nice idea - a few more weapons like that wouldn't hurt.

The Dagger of the Underworld is pretty good - although technically it is possible to have more than two hands in AH, so you might want to change it to 'if ALL your hands are empty' rather than 'both'.

Alternatively, you could choose to not care about the oddballs who have three hands, in which case a slightly more elegant phrasing would be "+1 to Combat checks, and a further +2 for each empty hand you have."

I like your new phrasing. Do you think it should cost $7? This is the price of Gladius of Carcosa, and they're pretty much the same power level, (the dagger gives +1 if both your hands are full and the gladius give +4 to one empty hand)

kroen said:

You seem to really enjoy handing out all three of those together these days, hehe. Seems like a perfectly ok card, as none of those 3 cards is exceptionally helpful and certainly not worth more than 4$ and some turns.

The Message said:

Also, you can't really make use of more than one of them anyway, as they all require you to be in different places, and unless you stick around for a few turns you're unlikely to get the really good results.

I think there aren't enough ways to get these memberships, actually. Well, not so much the Sheldon Gang, because I don't care about them much, but Goat Cult and Silver Lodge are both under-used imho.

kroen said:

It should be something like "Upkeep: You may discard this item to discard one of your (Injury/Madness) cards." Other than that, cool.

Thanks.

kroen said:

This ally is horrible. Looks cool though. I would never ever ever ever consider drawing her. If you changed her ability so it could close an open rift when you aquire her, then she would be of some utility, but as she is now, she's basically a +1 luck ally (how often does anyone actually want sneak— and even if one does, there are better allies who give sneak).

I want Sneak. Luck, on the other hand, does nothing for me. Interesting that we have completely opposite opinions on which stat is worthwhile...

Avi's right about the special ability though, Kroen. Removing one Rift progression marker is such a slight ability that this Ally isn't worth 10 toughness / 2 gates. Ally abilities tend to be much more powerful than this. An Ally that actually closed an open rift wouldn't be out of the question.

An ally that discarded all the rift progress markers wouldn't be out of the question.

-Frank

kroen said:

I dunno about you, but I've never felt more sane after drinking some water. Theme aside, this is too cheap for what it does as both of its effects are quite decent. I'd price it closer to 4-5.

4-5?! The Holy Water themselves cost 4, and you have to be in the church to turn the Water. Other than that, I think you're waaaay overestimating the power of 1 sanity and 1 stamina.

kroen said:

You're right, I was thinking Holy Water was $5. $3 seems fine but I still wouldn't object to 4. This game is essentially just resource management and versatility is key.

Two items I'm surprised haven't been made:

We haven't see this ally before...

best ally against altach-natcha?

kroen said:

Edit: **** it,where did it go? Anyway, it was an ally that give +1 focus and he when he joins you, you draw 1 ally.

kroen said:

Or against the rumor that requires an ally sacrifice, or with Join The Winning Team. Interesting.

Bottle Water and Diving gear in the 20's? lol I know another dimension but how much stuff from another dimension is going to be floating around lol

edit: lol treat "wasteland" as "arkham" it was from an abandoned expansion I made

Brace yourself for the most powerful weapon in the game:

edit: arr should be a magical weapon