Why no subskills for speed and luck?

By Guest, in Arkham Horror Second Edition

Speed can have a subskill of Reflexes, and Luck can have a subskill of Fate.

Thoughts?

There's no need for them. Speed's subset is movement points, which can be increased or decreased by certain effects, without increasing or decreasing the character's Speed. Luck checks hold the plurality of random encounters, which makes up for luck's unique "bonus." The four existing subskills are voluntary in nature, and Luck is not a voluntary thing, so it would not make sense to have a subset of a skill.

Tibs said:

There's no need for them. Speed's subset is movement points, which can be increased or decreased by certain effects, without increasing or decreasing the character's Speed. Luck checks hold the plurality of random encounters, which makes up for luck's unique "bonus." The four existing subskills are voluntary in nature, and Luck is not a voluntary thing, so it would not make sense to have a subset of a skill.

B I N G O

Tibs said:

There's no need for them. Speed's subset is movement points, which can be increased or decreased by certain effects, without increasing or decreasing the character's Speed. Luck checks hold the plurality of random encounters, which makes up for luck's unique "bonus." The four existing subskills are voluntary in nature, and Luck is not a voluntary thing, so it would not make sense to have a subset of a skill.

I guess that makes sense.

I think luck and fate i think it's two sides of one thing.People who don't believe in religion or mystics call it luck and people with deep religious belifs call it fate.

Why i can't edit my posts?Sorry for error it's night there