freebird285 said:
This an agreeable point, and if you know the 'fluff' you'll see some designs just seem to endure for a very long time. The USAF still has the B-52, the Marine Corps the Cobra, for example. That aside, I pretty much dislike every single one of those designs until the Eta Actis 2. I love the LAAT/i Gunship, but it's not spaceworthy ship, aside from a rarely used variant, they're all airspeeders. So, I guess if FFG thinks it's a marketable thing, they'll produce them, but I doubt I'll spend any money on 95* of what the Prequels have to offer.
The flaw in my original point about endurance, however, is that these ships clearly did not…they were replaced by the one's we see now. The N1 Naboo Starfighter was not a largely produced model, for example, as it was pretty much exclusively for Naboo. There may have been a few flown during the Rebellion Era, about the same way certain nations still utilize much older MiGs: Because they can't afford anything better. The only other 'fighter' the Rebellion has in it's Pre-Yavin arsenal is the Z-95 and the R-41, and I can guarantee that horrible looking thing won't make me reach for my wallet. It's not even that recognizable for avid players of the game it was designed for. The Z-95 may see the light of day, although I don't really see a need for it, either.
You have to consider how these things will fit into the mechanics of the game, as Norsehound so profoundly mentioned earlier. I just don't see how you can squeeze something like an N-1 into the game and keep it both competitive and keep it's stats 'honest'. It couldn't have better stats than a TIE Fighter or A-Wing, which means it's Hull would be at a 1 or 2, which means anything with a higher pilot skill is going to one-shot it. Sure it'd be cheap, but then you could swarm them…meaning you'll see 10 of them on a table, and they'll suddenly become the staple unit, instead of a rare one-off for filler. It'd have, what, maybe 1 attack at best? A lot of these ships would have to be designed at such margins they'd either be useless, or cheesey.
