I've got the Facebook Pages Manager installed on my phone now, so that should make keeping everyone up to day with those pics and stats much easier. Expect me to be putting information up on the podcast's Facebook page.
Moonboy Classic 2013 - February 1-3
Kennon said:
I've got the Facebook Pages Manager installed on my phone now, so that should make keeping everyone up to day with those pics and stats much easier. Expect me to be putting information up on the podcast's Facebook page.
Great news, I am looking forward to following the event so I really appreciates the updates.
Good luck moonboy jousters!
Results? Trends? Thoughts? Observations?
More info can be found on the Facebook page , including house, agenda, restricted breakdowns, but the final results were that Zeiler's updated Targ KotHH beat my Greyjoy Maesters in the finals.
Can you copy the stats here? I can't be the only one who doesn't use Facebook.
Sorry about the lack of updates on the forum, it’s way easier to post info from our phones on the Facebook page. So pretty much everything is going to be brought over from there (with a few modifications for where Will’s info was incomplete).
We had 16 for the melee (although I didn’t play in it, just watched for the first round before I had to head out) loaded with out of towners. I don’t have a lot of specific info about the tournament. I know the top four were Will Lentz, Ben Terpstra, David Jones, and Luke Reed with Will Lentz winning it in the end. I know he was playing a Martell control deck with Quentyn designed to take advantage of the different melee objectives we tried out for the tourney. Ask him for a better description of how the objectives made the tournament ‘cause I don’t know it.
We had 24 for the joust on Saturday with 6 states represented (MO, AR, OK, IA, IL, TN) as well as three former world champions (myself, Greg Atkinson, and Luke Reed) so there was some pretty stiff competition.
House Breakdown:
Martell 3
Lannister 3
Baratheon 4
Stark 6
Greyjoy 3
Targaryen 4
Neutral 1
Agenda Breakdown:
House of Dreams 7
The Maester’s Path 3
Knights of the Hollow Hill 6
City of Shadows 1
Kings of Summer 1
Knights of the Realm 1
Treaty with the Isles 1
The Power Behind the Throne 1
Wilding (The Free Folk, The Last Giants, Blood of the First Men) 1
Unknown 2 (possibly no agenda but I will update for sure once I get my hands on decklists as I don't remember seeing any no agenda players)
Restricted Card Breakdown:
Val 2
Search and Detain 4
Fury of the Dragon 1
Narrow Escape 2
No Restricted 3
Venomous Blade 1
Fear of Winter 1
The Maester’s Path 3
Fury of the Wolf 1
The Viper’s Bannermen 3
Pyromancer’s Cache 1
Castellan of the Rock 1
Fury of the Lion 1
We played 5 rounds of Swiss (although we only needed 4 since we had 1 undefeated after that amount of time) and then a cut to top 8 after a dinner break.
Top 8 Pairings:
Zach Bunn (Targ KotHH) v. Matt Phillips (Bara ???)
Will Lentz (Greyjoy TMP) v. Chris Kizer (Greyjoy HoD – Seastone Chair)
Greg Atkinson (Lanni Wildlings) v. Luke Reed (Stark TMP)
Brett Zeiler (Targ KotHH) v. Brett Vaughn (Stark TMP)
Top 4 Pairings:
Zach Bunn (Targ KotHH) v. Will Lentz (Greyjoy TMP)
Luke Reed (Stark TMP) v. Brett Zeiler (Targ KotHH)
Final Pairings:
Will Lentz (Greyjoy TMP) v. Brett Zeiler (Targ KotHH)
And I (Brett Zeiler) ended up winning for a Moonboy Classic two-peat after a really good game against Will (I only had one loss all day which was against Zach Bunn who was also playing Targ KotHH). I was playing a modified version of Bruno’s worlds deck (as I tend to do I “trimmed the fat, took out the bad cards, and put in some good ones”
) which is what I usually do when I do well in events. I’ll post a brief tourney report later this afternoon but be looking for a more in depth one on 2 Champs 1 Chump in the next few weeks.
I’ll have top 8 decklists posted later this evening after I run by the store to grab them and get them written up. Until then I hope this sates your thirst Dennis!
Muchas gracias amigos!
Congrats Brett.
I can hear the outcry now…"OH NO! A GOOD PLAYER WON WITH TARG KOTHH AGAIN?!?! WE NEED ERATTA/RESTRICTION! NOW!!!!
*sigh*
widowmaker93 said:
Congrats Brett.
I can hear the outcry now…"OH NO! A GOOD PLAYER WON WITH TARG KOTHH AGAIN?!?! WE NEED ERATTA/RESTRICTION! NOW!!!!
*sigh*
No, the exact outcry is : "OH NO! ANOTHER GOOD PLAYER WON WITH TARG KOTHH AND THERE ARE ONLY KOTHH AND MAESTERS IN TOP AGAIN ?!?! WE NEED ERATTA/RESTRICTION "PRONTO" !!!!
Looks like HOD didn't shift the meta at all. Or maybe just top players didn't take the risk.
msommi said:
widowmaker93 said:
Congrats Brett.
I can hear the outcry now…"OH NO! A GOOD PLAYER WON WITH TARG KOTHH AGAIN?!?! WE NEED ERATTA/RESTRICTION! NOW!!!!
*sigh*
No, the exact outcry is : "OH NO! ANOTHER GOOD PLAYER WON WITH TARG KOTHH AND THERE ARE ONLY KOTHH AND MAESTERS IN TOP AGAIN ?!?! WE NEED ERATTA/RESTRICTION "PRONTO" !!!!
Looks like HOD didn't shift the meta at all. Or maybe just top players didn't take the risk.
this is more along the lines of what i was thinking. Just sad that the meta hasnt shifted one iota since worlds.
dcdennis said:
this is more along the lines of what i was thinking. Just sad that the meta hasnt shifted one iota since worlds.
To be fair, all we got since worlds was a single chapter pack with a middling agenda.
I don't think things are all that stale; the top 8 had a HoD deck, a Bara deck, and a Lanni WIldlings deck. Sure, people gravitated toward Targ KoTHH after Bruno won Worlds with it, but that was to be expected. I actually think that the MoonBoy decklists look relatively diverse. It is encouraging more than anything.
Yeah I guess Lanny HoD w/Tunnels wasn't a big determent to playing Targ.
Brett Vaughn - Stark The Maester’s Path
Characters:
Hodor x1
Arya Stark (BtNS) x1
Ser Kyle Condon x2
Follower of the Many-Faced God x3
Maester Vyman x2
Meera Reed x2
Eddard Stark (CS) x2
Maester Luwin x2
Oldtown Scholar x3
Bolton Refugee x3
Midnight Sentry x3
Leyton Hightower x1
Royal Guard x1
Carrion Bird x1
Knight of Harrenhal x1
Old Nan x2
The Conclave x1
The Kindly Man x1
Locations:
Godswood x1
Narrow Sea x2
Northern Fiefdom x3
The Citadel of Oldtown x1
Den of the Wolf
Great Keep x2
Street of Sisters x1
Lord Eddard’s Chambers x1
Events:
Dissension x3
The Hand’s Judgment x2
Paper Shield x2
No Quarter x1
Attachments:
Frozen Solid x1
Bastard x1
Maester Malleon’s Tome x1
Milk of the Poppy x2
White Raven x1
Apprentice Collar x1
Copper Link x1
Black Iron Link x1
Brass Link x1
Bronze Link x1
Tin Link x1
Valyrian Steel Link x1
Plots:
Valar Morghulis
The Minstrel’s Muse
Twist of Fate
Outwit
Respect of the Old Gods
Forgotten Plans
At the Gates
Greg Atkinson – Lannister Wildlings (Blood of the First Men, The Free Folk, The Last Giants)
Characters:
Mountain Refugee x3
Free Man x2
Carrion Bird x3
Samwell Tarly x2
Campfire Mime x3
Painted Dogs x2
Craster x1
Val x2
Varamyr Sixskins x1
Qyburn x1
Chella, Daughter of Cheyk x2
Ser Aerys Oakheart x1
Mance Rayder (AToR) x1
Orell the Eagle x1
The Wildling Horde x3
Wintertime Marauders x1
Cersei Lannister (LotR) x1
Locations:
Pentoshi Manor x3
The Iron Throne (LotR) x1
Golden Tooth Mines x3
Sunset Sea x3
The Goldroad x3
The Roseroad x1
River Row x1
Shadowblack Lane x1
Street of Steel x1
The Land Beyond the Wall x1
Events:
Dissension x2
Nightmares x2
Support of the Kingdom x3
Attachments:
Enslaved x3
Taxed Dry x3
White Raven x2
Plots:
A Time for Ravens
The Winds of Winter
Valar Morghulis
The Songs of Bael the Bard
Twist of Fate
Retaliation!
Blockade
Matt Phillips – Baratheon House of Dreams
Characters:
Knight of Flowers (KL) x1
Shireen Baratheon (SoO) x3
Bastard of Robert x1
Willas Tyrell x2
Vale Refugee x3
Acolyte of the Flame x3
Highgarden Refugee x3
Selyse Baratheon (CS) x2
Zealot of the Light x2
Dragonstone Convert x3
Melisandre (???) x3
Herald of the Stag x2
Watcher of the Nightfire x3
Locations:
Smuggler’s Cove x2
King Robert’s Chambers x1
Altar of Fire x3
Narrow Sea x3
Seat of Power x3
Street of Sisters x1
Shadowblack Lane x1
The Roseroad x2
The Searoad x2
The Iron Throne (DotN) x1
Event:
Terminal Schemes x3
Narrow Sea x3
Confession x2
Condemned by the Council x2
Attachments:
Plots:
The Red Wedding
Valar Morghulis
The Power of Faith x2
Shadows and Spiders
Many Powers Long Asleep
The Art of Seduction
Chris Kizer – Greyjoy House of Dreams
Characters:
Newly Made Lord x3
Kingsmoot Hopeful x3
Tarle the Thrice-Drowned x1
Maester Wendamyr x1
Asha Greyjoy (ToC) x3
Theon Greyjoy (ToC) x1
The Knight x1
Moqorro x1
The Sparr x1
Baelor Blacktyde x2
Gylbert Farwynd x2
Euron Crow’s Eye (ToC) x3
Aeron Damphair (KotS) x1
Drowned Disciple x1
Locations:
Sunset Sea x3
Street of Steel x1
Street of Sisters x1
Street of Silk x1
Shadowblack Lane x1
River Row x1
Ocean Road x1
Longship Iron Victory x1
Aeron’s Chambers x1
The Iron Mines x3
The Iron Cliffs x2
Scouting Vessel x3
Corpse Lake x2
Fishmonger’s Square x1
The Seastone Chair x1
Events:
Finger Dance x2
Risen from the Sea x3
Assault of the Kraken x3
Attachments:
Support of Harlaw x2
Support of Saltcliffe x1
Driftwood Crown x2
Captain of the Iron Fleet x1
Plots:
Loyalty Money Can Buy
Valar Morghulis
The Power of Blood x2
Desolate Passage
Rise of the Kraken
Search and Detain
Zach Bunn – Targaryen Knights of the Hollow Hill
Characters:
Magister Illyrio (BtNS) x3
Dragon Knight x3
Killer of the Wounded x2
Dragon Thief x2
Khal Drogo (CS) x2
Long Lances x3
Shadow Parasite x2
King’s Landing Assassin x3
Sorrowful Man x2
Young Griff x1
The Brazen Beasts x1
Lyanna Stark x1
Ser Barristan Selmy (ToC) x2
Syrio Forel x2
Locations:
Eastern Fiefdom x3
King’s Landing x2
The Dragonpit x2
The Red Keep x2
Lady Daenerys’s Chambers x1
Meereen Tourney Grounds x1
Events:
The Hatchling’s Feast x3
Incinerate x3
Forever Burning x3
Favorable Ground x2
To Be a Dragon x2
Ambush from the Plains x1
Attachments:
Flame-Kissed x3
Dragon Skull x3
Plots:
Threat from the North
Rule by Decree
Marched to the Wall
Fury of the Dragon
Valar Morghulis
City of Spiders
City of Lies
RESERVED FOR LUCAS REED'S DECKLIST ONCE I GET IT
Will Lentz – Greyjoy The Maester’s Path
Characters:
Maester Murenmure x1
Maester Wendamyr x1
The Conclave x3
Carrion Bird x3
Moqorro x1
Asha Greyjoy (ToC) x1
Baelor Blacktyde x1
Distinguished Boatswain x3
Alannys Greyjoy (ToC) x1
Island Refugee x3
Oldtown Advisor x3
Leyton Hightower x1
Ser Aery’s Oakheart x1
Wex Pyke x1
Locations:
Sunset Sea x3
Shadowblack Lane x1
Street of Sisters x1
Street of Steel x1
Gatehouse x3
Longship Iron Victory x2
The Iron Mines x3
The Iron Cliffs x2
Events:
Finger Dance x3
Citadel Law x3
Dissension x3
Risen from the Sea x2
Attachments:
Apprentice Collar x1
Bronze Link x1
Copper Link x1
Gold Link x1
Lead Link x1
Tin Link x1
Valyrian Steel Link x1
Horn of Dragons x1
Plots:
A City Besieged
At the Gates
City of Sin
City of Soldiers
City of Spiders
Valar Morghulis
Songs of Bael the Bard
Brett Zeiler – Targaryen Knights of the Hollow Hill
Characters:
Carrion Bird x2
Sellsword Deserter x1
Street Waif x3
Dragon Knight x2
Dragon Theif x3
Magister Illyrio (BtNS) x1
Young Griff x1
Ser Jorah Mormont (ToC) x1
Daario Naharis (ToC) x1
Long Lances x3
Jhogo (BWB) x1
Pyat Pree x1
Company of the Cat x2
Khal Drogo (CS) x1
Daenerys Targaryen (SoO) x1
Viserion (QoD) x1
Locations:
Bay of Ice x2
Summer Sea x3
Meereenese Brothel x1
Meereen Tourney Grounds x1
Eastern Fiefdom x3
Meraxes x1
Kingsroad Fiefdom x2
Great Pyramid of Meereen x1
The Red Keep x1
Aegon’s Hill x2
Rhaenys’s Hill x1
Events:
Ambush from the Plains x2
Incinerate x2
Confession x2
Much and More x2
The Hatchling’s Feast x2
To Be a Dragon x1
Too Proud to Bow x1
Recruitment x2
Attachments:
Flame-Kissed x3
Plots:
Valar Morghulis
Marched to the Wall
The First Snow of Winter
Rule by Decree
Search and Detain
Waste Their Time
Threat from the North
And there are the top 8 Moonboy Classic 2013 decklists (aside from Luke's which I'm still waiting on)! As promised I have a quick tourney report but tune into 2 Champs 1 Chump next week to hear a slightly more detailed version!
After seeing Bruno playing his deck at Worlds it looked like a ton of fun and built it up pretty much immediately. It did in fact turn out to be a blast to play and once I trimmed it down to 60 and made a few swaps (the Too Proud to Bow was put in at the last minute by taking out a The Hatchling's Feast to have a little tech against wildings and maesters; it was pretty average all day until finals against WIll where it pretty much won me the game). I'm not saying my version is any better than Bruno's although it's more to my tastes and I'd recommend giving it a try.
Round 1 I played against Danny from IA who was also playing Targ KotHH. She told me before the game started that she hadn't every played the deck before and that someone else had given it to her to play. If she had been a little more aggressive with Aegon's Hill and Meereen Tourney Grounds it may have changed the game but in the end I just had answers to all the guys she played and rode it out to victory. 1-0
Round 2 was against someone whose name I've honestly forgotten (sorry man I'm awful with names until I've met you several times; ask the Tulsa guys who I still get mixed up all the time!) playing Martell KotHH. Again this would have been a very different game had he been packing Valar in his plot deck but without it he wasn't able to compensate for the guys I was killing and keeping him from winning challenges. 2-0
Round 3 was against none other than local superstar Greg Atkinson and his Lanni Wildling deck. This was the only game all day that Rule by Decree did what it was supposed to for me (in all the others I usually played it when both players had few cards in hand just to make sure it didn't bite me later) but I did make Greg discard ~10 cards on plot 2. I also had Aegon's Hill doing work all game which killed off several Wilding Hordes and other unique characters. Greg did get off to an early lead in board position and power but I was able to kill off enough guys to stabilize and bring in the win just in the nick of time. The biggest play of the game was on the last turn using Much and More into Rhaenys's Hill to steal 10ish guys out of his discard pile and swoop in for a dominant challenge phase. 3-0
Round 4 was against Brett Vaughn from AR playing a really cool Stark Maester deck. He was playing Follower of the Many-Faced God and stalwart guys to stand his maesters with chains as well as guaranteeing he always had a board full of guys. For the first several rounds I was playing near Brett and anytime I looked over he always had a ton of guys in play no matter what point of the game he was in. This was a super tight game than came down to the wire. When I won it he had 15 power but still had 1 chain left to move off his agenda. He also played 3 Dissensions against me this game and that was pretty infuriating
. 4-0
Round 5 was against Zach Bunn from OK playing another (very different) Targ KotHH deck. I got pretty much stomped all game starting on plot 1: I had Much and More for the first time all day in my opening hand and used Rule by Decree as my first plot. He had City of Lies to counter it and luckily only had 1 shadows card to put it making my Rule by Decree do nothing rather than making me discard down to 4. Still he had all the tricks all game and I never really got a foothold leading to my first loss of the day. 4-1, making the cut as the second seed in top 8
Top 8 was against Brett Vaughn again and this game was as different as possible from our match in Swiss. He couldn't seem to play a card I didn't have an answer to and rode it out to a pretty quick victory.
Top 4 was against Luke Reed's Stark Maesters in probably my toughest match all day (that I won at least). He had a pretty firm grip on the game with several Northern Cavalry Flanks and 2 Northern Outposts making it pretty much impossible for me to win a challenge on attack without stealth although I did well enough in intrigues and winning a few random challenges here and there to get up to 6 or 7 power. This game came down to time as Luke had 1 chain left of his house card I all I had to do was play defensively and keep him form moving it off for the win since he was at 12 power. Had we been playing without time I think I probably would have had the game anyways as I had board position and he was drawing off the top every turn.
Finals was against Will Lentz and his Greyjoy Maester deck, and for the details of this game you should probably tune into the next episode of 2C1C to hear more!
Sorry, i cant resist. Im posting from my phone so it isnt pretty.
While a small sampling, it is clear as of now HOD hasnt really changed much. Maybe not as broken as suggested, and certainly no substitute for new packs in a stale meta. Congrats to the winner, but im excited for a fresh cycle.
Thanks guys for all the stats/updates here and on FB. Congrats to the winner!
Sounds like a good turnout and a nice variety of decks/agendas/restricted cards were represented (although maybe not in the Top 4…)