When i roll a 1 do i move both of them or do i choose one or how does that work exactly?

In our games, we pick which one to move when a "1" is rolled (adds a little bit of strategy), but I've heard of others who move both.

I'd say it's your choice.

kain7th said:

According to the rules if you roll a 1 you must move the Werewolf but the Reaper is optional. Before Werewolf came in to play if someone forgot to move Reaper before the next persons turn started he lost his chance. Now this is a bit harder since you have to remember eachother to move the Werewolf then forgetting to move the Reaper rarely happens.

So to answer your question Werewolf must be moved and Reaper is optional on a roll of 1

thanks for the reply, i think im going to make a house rule, where the werewolf moves when someone rolls a two instead. it's just easier to remember for me lol.