This game was so sad!!! I lost Gollem in the fourth turn or so and re-shuffled him back into the deck.
I was playing a solo game with my my Rohan based mono-spirit deck, so I managed to keep my threat down while trying to whittle away the deck to find him again. By the end I had about my entire deck of allies in play, had used all my Gandalfs just to lower my threat, and was waiting for a Dwarven tomb to get a Greeting card back.
I hit 50 threat with 5 cards left in the encounter deck. Gollem was on the very bottom… Dwarven tomb was the next card in my deck….