Just got my copy….and it seems like from what I can see, the cards in Blood Moon have a higher than average quality in terms of creativity and fun. I still think that the werewolf NPC could have been handled in a way that makes it more substantially different than the reaper, but all in all it's not too bad either. Because we play with the ice queen and the toad king too, I forget sometimes that this is only the second 'official' NPC, and that not everybody's board is getting crowded with them. I like the expansion a lot more than I thought I might. Can't wait to actually play it.
For those who are having trouble managing the NPCs and dragon scales, etc., I've made a template for printing graphics onto standard 5/8" dice via printable stickers. We roll one of these along with our movement die; on 1, the reaper moves the same number of spaces you do. On 2, the toad king moves (if you don't use him, ignore the graphic or find some other use for it). He also still moves when magic items are drawn or spells cast. On a 3 or 4, we draw a dragon scale if we're using that expansion. On a 5, the werewolf moves. On a 6, the ice queen. We also use the die for standard monster combat. It seems pretty efficient, and I like the look of them. You can download them in the 'downloads' section of talismanisland.com
cheers!