Radwraith said:
I have to disagree here. I have no problem with the player emphasizing the "know no fear!" part of the SM ethos. But as has been posted earlier; There are critters out there that WILL stomp your fearless hero into red goo if they do not excersize some tactical preparedness! At higher levels your character joins the ranks of Kayvaan Shrike, Ragnar Blackmane and Marneus Calgar (Although a chapter master would undoubtedly be level 8!)! These types of characters have historically engaged in legendary feats of martial prowess! Why should your character be any different? That being said, The Caveat is still "Stupid hurts!" If you play your character as brash but tactically sound I would reward your efforts. If you insist on charging the Carnifex with your combat knife, plan on a heroic sacrifice!
I have no problem with Marines being badass. They can certainly engage in feats of epic awesomeness and there's no reason for them to be afraid. But a game where the PCs never need to think about what they are doing? Where they never need to worry about being killed in combat? That's some boring crap right there. I cannot emphasise enough how much I would hate such a game.
