Newb ?'s

By Hastur360, in 2. AGoT Rules Discussion

I have a couple of newb questions.

First if my opponent has the Crown of Winter in play, and it is currently Winter. What happens if I put the Crown of Mereen into play? Is it both summer and winter? I know that the White Raven and Black Raven cards knock each other out of play but what happens with the crowns?

Second question. If I have Darkstar (either version) in play and then an opponent makes me discard Darkstar (from Princes of the Sun) from my hand can I attach the older version as a duplicate to Darkstar or is it actually discarded because I cannot play it?

Thanks ahead of time for any answers.

Sorry for the double post. The forums seem to be laggy.

Hastur360 said:

I have a couple of newb questions.

First if my opponent has the Crown of Winter in play, and it is currently Winter. What happens if I put the Crown of Mereen into play? Is it both summer and winter? I know that the White Raven and Black Raven cards knock each other out of play but what happens with the crowns?

It is both summer and winter. In most circumstances this is fairly easily resolved. In the case where it activates two conflicting passives (say in the case of Fairweather Followers), the first player chooses in which order the passives resolve (resulting in the character either standing or kneeling.)

Hastur360 said:

Second question. If I have Darkstar (either version) in play and then an opponent makes me discard Darkstar (from Princes of the Sun) from my hand can I attach the older version as a duplicate to Darkstar or is it actually discarded because I cannot play it?

Thanks ahead of time for any answers.

You can't play it because playing it involves choosing to play it from your hand, and it is being discarded. However, Darkstar's ability doesn't say to "play" it. It says to put it into play. The FAQ states: "You may not play, put into play, or take control of a unique card already in play that you own or control (except for putting a duplicate on a card that you own and control). So, you put this card into play, and as per the FAQ you can only play or put into play a copy of a unique card if you are attaching it as a duplicate. So you can do that.