Knelt Characters and Narrow Escape

By bbleers, in 2. AGoT Rules Discussion

If my opponent kneels 3 characters who then die (via lethal counterattack for example), do the characters return standing or knelt as they were when they left play?

Narrow escape doesn't prevent them from leaving play, it brings them (back) into play. It would have no memory of the standing or kneeling nature of the character. The characters would be standing (or not) depending on any effects that affect their standing as they come into play.

-Istaril said:

Narrow escape doesn't prevent them from leaving play, it brings them (back) into play. It would have no memory of the standing or kneeling nature of the character. The characters would be standing (or not) depending on any effects that affect their standing as they come into play.

If Catelyn Stark (KL) is killed after jumped into play, then will she comes back to hand at the end of phase if she was narrow escaped.

Uncle Joker said:

If Catelyn Stark (KL) is killed after jumped into play, then will she comes back to hand at the end of phase if she was narrow escaped.

No. Once she leaves play, there is no memory of the lasting effect her ability set into place before she died.

By the way, you surely mean Catelyn Stark (LoW), she is the one who would go back to your hand at the end of the phase. Catelyn Stark (KL) is the one who can prevent INT challenges against you.

So if I understand you correctly it would shake down like this. Opponent initiates his first challenge and attacks with 3 characters, I play Lethal Counterattack, his characters die, he plays Narrow Escape and his characters come back (standing unless I do something to kneel them) and are available for intrigue and power challenges? Also, am I correct to assume that power on those characters is lost?

bbleers said:

Opponent initiates his first challenge and attacks with 3 characters, I play Lethal Counterattack, his characters die, he plays Narrow Escape and his characters come back (standing unless I do something to kneel them) and are available for intrigue and power challenges?

Yes, that's correct.

bbleers said:


Also, am I correct to assume that power on those characters is lost?

Yes, all power and attachments would have been discarded when the characters left play... its important to remember that NE is not a save effect.