some questions

By player13022, in 2. AGoT Rules Discussion

1. May I play "He Calls it Thinking" to cancel an action or I can only use it to cancel some printed "response" effect on the cards ?

2. I had Tyrion Lannister(the shadow one) in play and is revealed. May I directly put another Tyrion Lannister(the shadow one) in my hand as a duplicate on him?

thx for answering

spring10345 said:

1. May I play "He Calls it Thinking" to cancel an action or I can only use it to cancel some printed "response" effect on the cards ?

2. I had Tyrion Lannister(the shadow one) in play and is revealed. May I directly put another Tyrion Lannister(the shadow one) in my hand as a duplicate on him?

thx for answering

1. Actions and Responses are two entirely different things, and they are triggered at entirely different points in the timing structure. Only card effects that are prefaced Response: or Limited Response: are Responses, and only those effects can be cancelled with HCiT (as long as they don't have an influence cost).

2. Yes, you can attach a copy of KL Tyrion (or any other Tyrion, for that matter) directly from your hand as a duplicate on your KL Tyrion already in play. You can also play the second copy of KL Tyrion into Shadows first and attach it as a dupe after it comes out of shadows. The choice is yours. See here.