Herman Goering Panzer Division vs. 1st Ranger Battalion Campaign: Feedback Desired!!!

By player674990, in Tide of Iron

What I've got:

I. Invasion of Gela
July 10, 1943

1st Ranger Battalion Objectives
1. Destroy the 2 gun batteries.
2. Penetrate through enemy lines of resistance to Cathedral Square.

4th Italian Livorno Division Objectives
1. Occupy the 2 gun batteries.
2. Destroy all enemy officers.
3. Retreat to Cathedral Square if beach defenses are breached.


II. 504 on the Killing Floor
July 12, 1943

Fallschirm-Panzer-Division 1 Hermann Göring Objectives
1. Occupy ? manor.

504th PIR Objectives
1. Occupy ? manor.


III. Counter Attack at Gela
July 11-12, 1943

1st Ranger Battalion Objectives
1. Occupy Cathedral Square.

4th Italian Livorno Division Objectives
1. Occupy Cathedral Square.


IV. Amo Amalfi
September X, 1943

Fallschirm-Panzerkorps Hermann Göring Objectives
1. [They do something.]

Insert American Throw-Away Division Here
1. [They do something too.]


V. Defense of Chiunzi Pass
November X, 1943

1st Ranger Battalion Objectives
1. Occupy Chiunzi Pass.
2. Halt all enemy supplies.

Fallschirm-Panzerkorps Hermann Göring Objectives
1. Defend supply convoys through enemy lines of resistance.


VI. On the Line
November X, 1943

Fallschirm-Panzerkorps Hermann Göring Objectives
1. [They do something.]

Throwaway Allied Division Objectives
1. [The do something as well.]


VII. Naples Plain
December X, 1943

1st Ranger Battalion Objectives
1. Pierce enemy main lines of resistance.
2. Occupy points of interest deep within enemy territory until reinforcements arrive.

Fallschirm-Panzerkorps Hermann Göring Objectives
1. Delay enemy forces until evacuation is complete.
2. Destroy any points of enemy interest.


VIII. Cisterna
January 31, 1944

1st Ranger Battalion Objectives
1. Penetrate enemy main lines of resistance.
2. Occupy train station.

Fallschirm-Panzerkorps Hermann Göring Objectives
1. Neutralize all enemy threats.

Panzer Lehr Battalion Objectives
1. Neutralize all enemy threats.

That would be my structure, equal amount of battles, chances for experience, different tactics, etc. Note: I will be remaking the Blood on the Mountain scenario for veteran players... maybe retitle it Blood on the Bloody Slopes of Blood Mountain II: Blood Bath Boogaloo...

Any suggestions? Again, I'm using 2 Copies of the Base game and shall restrict myself to 1 copy apiece for both DotF and Normandy. .. unless I pick up another copy of Normandy...

Also: I'm creating the Ranger Canon Company--which consisted of 4 M3A1 Half-Tracks outfitted with salvaged 75mm Italian guns from Sicily. It would be available as a reinforcement element to the rangers beginning with these stats:

Canon Company
4 M3A1 Half-Track 75mm AT Guns
versus Infantry Range: 5 Firepower: 4
versus Vehicles Range: 6 Firepower: 8
Movement: 7 Armor: 1
May not use Transport ability
Concussive Firepower

Too powerful? Glad to hear ANY input...

Note: I may use the Panzer Lehr Division for a Normandy campaign at some point, hence it's inclusion at the last battle of Cisterna...

First of all, I like the idea of following two "hero" companies through the campaign and having them meet in some scenarios.

7times7is49 said:

Canon Company
4 M3A1 Half-Track 75mm AT Guns
versus Infantry Range: 5 Firepower: 4
versus Vehicles Range: 6 Firepower: 8
Movement: 7 Armor: 1
May not use Transport ability
Concussive Firepower

Too powerful? Glad to hear ANY input...

In the Designer Series book, page 81, Vance von Borries uses US half-tracks with 75mm guns, giving them a firepower of 6 versus vehicles. The rest of the stats are identical to yours. His scenario is set in North Africa, though, so I do not know if the guns he had in mind are the same as on your half-tracks, even though they have the same caliber.

7times7is49 said:

Canon Company
4 M3A1 Half-Track 75mm AT Guns
versus Infantry Range: 5 Firepower: 4
versus Vehicles Range: 6 Firepower: 8
Movement: 7 Armor: 1
May not use Transport ability
Concussive Firepower

Too powerful? Glad to hear ANY input...

In Flames of War, the M3 75mm GMC half-track has only marginally less firepower versus vehicles (firepower 9) than the M4A1 Sherman (firepower 10) and the same values for range and rate of fire.