Kennon said:
Just for curiosity's sake, Longclaw, what about the deal that I broke with Dobbler up in MN? Discarding the Horn of Dragons didn't win me the game (at least not directly that turn) but it sure kept me from losing as Dobbler used my character every turn.
~Obviously you are in the right since Greg is playing such a scary attachment.
I'm sure triggering Scurvy Cutthroat was just a knee-jerk reaction, right?
Seriously, though, it's hard to say without knowing the board the and feel for the game at that particular moment, along with a ton of other little things. Even though I was joking earlier, Horn of Dragons is a pretty big threat, and you likely had no way of taking care of it at a later date in that deck when the game was at an end (I think the Cutthroat was probably your only attachment removal?).
I am sure that there are a great number of players, who, in your shoes, would have done the same thing (not that that particular argument ever justifies anything, of course, but just pointing it out).