shadows Tyrion, No Attachments and existing attachments

By LaughingTree, in 2. AGoT Rules Discussion

When a card comes out of Shadows and shadow Tyrion's player choose "No Attachments" do all existing attachments on Tyrion then fall off?

Yes. "No attachments" means "no attachments." Any on him would become illegal and thus fall off.

lol... ~that guy's a cheater, and whoever was TO was blind!

We were all so wrapped up in the order of responses, this never even crossed our minds. Sorry man sad.gif

@Ktom, thanks for clearing that up.

Deathjester26 said:

lol... ~that guy's a cheater, and whoever was TO was blind!

We were all so wrapped up in the order of responses, this never even crossed our minds. Sorry man sad.gif

Haha no worries, it didnt cross my mind either till replaying the game on way back to LA. Better to know that stuff now than learn it at Kubla =D

Lol, unless the attachment was Milk of the Poppy! gran_risa.gif

cha0s said:

Lol, unless the attachment was Milk of the Poppy! gran_risa.gif

If the attachment was Milk of the Poppy, Tyrion would not be able to get "No Attachments" from his own ability in the first place - since his ability is obviously not there to trigger. But if he gained "No Attachments" from some other source, Milk of the Poppy would indeed fall off.

I just don't want someone to read that and think that gaining "No Attachments" wouldn't affect Milk of the Poppy.