I was looking at this last night and it says that the american sherman tanks are really M10 tank destroyers. I have a couple of questions about that.

1. It has different stats for those M10s then the M10 stats from Normandy. Do I use the stats from Normandy since it has accual M10s or the stats from the scenario?

2. It says "the sherman tanks are m10s with these differences:..." Are those the diferences from the sherman tank stats from the basic game ot the M10 stats from the normandy expansion?

Seeing as the designer series was in production separately from Normandy, I would go with the book and ignore the Normandy M10 rules.

Scenario specific rules always replace other ToI rules. Any complaints someone has with the ToI rules can be solved by writing a fan scenario! Anyone can have the rules anyway they want in a scenario they have written themselves.

I have tried this scenario twice(as the Germans) and lost both game... We have played with the Normandy M10 rules.

Tell me if the German player win this scenario.