Keeper Cards - Design idea

By Lyker, in Mansions of Madness

Since there has been a lot of errata etc about some keeper cards are only allowed to play once, this is my suggestion for upcoming expansion.

base rule is:

*Keeper cards can never be played more then once preforming the exact same action.

(e.g not move the same monster twice. Not use UU on same investigator twice to move, but move and action is ok etc)

*Add a infinity marker on Keeper cards that can be played multiple times.

What do you think Corey?

Lyker said:

*Keeper cards can never be played more then once preforming the exact same action.

If the rule manages to get into the default set of rules, please explain "the exact same action". Otherwise we'd still end up with "Can I use UU on the same investigator, or is this the exact same action?"
Exact same action = Same Action Card, same target, same choice of action, if there is one.

Elbi said:

Lyker said:

*Keeper cards can never be played more then once preforming the exact same action.

If the rule manages to get into the default set of rules, please explain "the exact same action". Otherwise we'd still end up with "Can I use UU on the same investigator, or is this the exact same action?"
Exact same action = Same Action Card, same target, same choice of action, if there is one.

I wrote about UU in my example.

Exact same action would be move the investigator twice. (not legit) One move and one action would be legit.

Lyker said:

Elbi said:

Lyker said:

*Keeper cards can never be played more then once preforming the exact same action.

If the rule manages to get into the default set of rules, please explain "the exact same action". Otherwise we'd still end up with "Can I use UU on the same investigator, or is this the exact same action?"
Exact same action = Same Action Card, same target, same choice of action, if there is one.

I wrote about UU in my example.

Exact same action would be move the investigator twice. (not legit) One move and one action would be legit.

"May not perform the exact same action" is incredibly difficult to specify in rules terms. UU would need an FAQ all to itself if this was implemented as an official rule.