I love the scar card and destination from Pegasus, its always seemed very thematic, and I want to keep using it with Exodus. Does anyone think it would be unbalanced to play with that single attack Crisis?

My group felt the same way,..and so we have left it in as the only cylon attack crisis. However, we soon realized that even this one card is DEVESTATING when it comes up. To make a long story short, after some deliberation we decided to still leave it in there however we say that no civie ships come out and the extra raider doesnt come out....ONLY scar pops...we still are debating whether the Activation raider takes effect but in general I think it should since ANY crisis could have that and to take that away hinders the cylons too much.

Napoleon

That is how we play. We keep the Scar attack card and the scar destination card in the deck.
When the fleet jumps we remove Scar from the board.

I think it works fine.

We took out the crisis card, but kept the destination, and it did come up already in the six games we've played. When it did, we put up the scar marker and treated it as a raider (for purposes of all activation), which can only be destroyed by 7 or 8. When we jumped it went to the CFB, and even came back once.