Dunwich Horror - 3 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 3 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 6 (hurt)
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
because luke with the white ship is pure fun.
and i haven't played with innsmouth, so i do not know the ups and downs of that board.
Dunwich Horror - 2 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 2 (hurtl)
Innsmouth Horror - 7 (heal)
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Not if I have anything to say about it, JGT!
Dunwich Horror - 3 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 1 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 6 (hurt)
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Oh snap!
DIE! DIE! DIE!
Dunwich Horror - 4 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 0 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 5 (hurt)
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Man that feels good. All the lurking pays off 
!
Dam ex machina
subochre said:
Dam ex machina
Dam da da da DAAAAAM.
BWAHAHAHAHAAAA!!! hilarious! the Kingsport haters actually got worried enough to rig the vote! classic!
...?
If he had been genuinely worried, you'd think that instead of spending all this time lurking in preparation for his dramatic (damatic?) entrance, he would have spent it voting against Kingsport. However I am intrigued by this idea that one can rig a vote by abstaining from it. 
subochre said:
...?
If he had been genuinely worried, you'd think that instead of spending all this time lurking in preparation for his dramatic (damatic?) entrance, he would have spent it voting against Kingsport. However I am intrigued by this idea that one can rig a vote by abstaining from it.
Yes. Ninja voting. Also a dangerous phenomenon.
Dunwich Horror - 3 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 6 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
subochre said:
...?
If he had been genuinely worried, you'd think that instead of spending all this time lurking in preparation for his dramatic (damatic?) entrance, he would have spent it voting against Kingsport. However I am intrigued by this idea that one can rig a vote by abstaining from it.
oh, theres always a way in the mythos captain naivete
like pm for instance
Dunwich Horror - 4 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 5 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Dunwich Horror - 3 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 6 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
This is a sad stalemated state of affairs, will some other people please come in and mercy kill one of these boxes?
Avi_dreader said:
This is a sad stalemated state of affairs, will some other people please come in and mercy kill one of these boxes?
SURE!
Dunwich Horror - 2 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror -7 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Dunwich Horror - 3 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror -6 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
HARDLY.
Taurmindo said:
HARDLY.
avec said:
Solan said:
I'm firmly of the opinion that all of the small box expansions are far inferior to any of the Horrors; they just can't equal the allure of new boards, new characters and new Ancient Ones.
That's kind of the problem. I can predict how this game will end: Black Goat, Dark Pharaoh, King in Yellow, Lurker, Kingsport, Dunwich, Innsmouth. Yawn. The only nailbiter will be whether Dunwich can edge out Innsmouth for the #1 spot. Now, if a small box can edge out a big box, things may get interesting.
I didn't predict the weird Lurker hate. But everything else... just sayin'
Julia said:
Taurmindo said:
HARDLY.
Evil.
We approve ;'D
Dunwich Horror - 2 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror -7 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Innsmouth is clearly harder and I need that difficulty
dj2.0 said:
So why did Black Goat get dropped first 
?
Dunwich Horror - 1 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror -8 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
DIE DIE DIE!
Oh, and Dam, because it presented itself as awesome fluff'n'flavor. And then failed. Though the Herald is greatly appreciated (which is why Lurker was next, I feel...)
Dunwich Horror - 2 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror -7 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Back from the brink!
Dam said:
So why did Black Goat get dropped first ?
yeah i do not agree with that result, personally. BG has taken a lot of flak from the cult membership, rightfully so given its rarity, but the herald is awesome, if you want a quick game. I wouldnt rank it lower than Curse.
Dunwich Horror - 1 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror -7 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Almost there...
Regarding Dark Pharaoh: when all you have are theme and bad mechanics, the theme wears thin pretty quickly. And, granted, Black Goat doesn't even have that much, but I think I'd also rank it higher, because at least its theme and mechanics are interestingly bad (thankfully, because otherwise all it would have going for it are gate bursts).
Here we go...
Dunwich Horror - 0 (hurt)
Black Goat of the Woods - 1 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror -7
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
Just kidding...
Dunwich Horror - 0 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror -8 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 0
The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
The Professor
o_O
I almost killed you :-p