Curse of the Dark Pharaoh - 0
Dunwich Horror - 9
The King in Yellow - 2 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 6 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 16 (heal)
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0

Heh... Still fighting the lost cause subochre?

I'm prepared to call it a draw

subochre said:

A wise choice. There is no way on Yuggoth Im going to be convinced that good use of what you have makes up for size

Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
Dunwich Horror - 8 (hurt)
The King in Yellow - 2
Kingsport Horror - 7 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 16
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0 (hurt)

Dunwich is a worse Innsmouth, while Kingsport board is always threatening and different from any other expansion boards. And sometimes it's funny stabbing a dead expansions (for some extra trophies)

Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
Dunwich Horror - 9(heal)
The King in Yellow - 1(hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 6 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 16
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0

The King in Yellow is down! Finish him!

Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
Dunwich Horror - 10 (heal)
The King in Yellow - 0(hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 5 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 16
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0

Because Dunwich is fun, and even if it's not super-active, you can still get 5 free clues (and possibly some new allies!). And Harney Jones' shack is an adorable idea. When I read the encounter where he dies I thought it was sad. But really neat!

Sorry KiY, time to let the big boys shine. Oh, and we all know why I like Innsmouth. So...it's not that I dislike Kingsport...it's just next on the list in my mind...

(edit: woah! Ninja'ed! Ask and ye shall receive Solan!)

Dunwich Horror - 9 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 6 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 16

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0
(reorganized by order of elimination)

Dunwich is still prone to unpredictable dilution.
Kingsport never is.
I don't want to hurt Innsmouth. Won't take long to call it the winner anyway.

hmm, tough choice, but today i feel like this:

Dunwich Horror - 8 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 7 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 15 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

because Kingsport is still unexplored here, with some locations not being reached too often.

EcnoTheNeato said:

You killed The King! ELVIS! NOOOOOOOO!

Dunwich Horror - 9 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 6 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 14 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Nothing personal Innsmouth ;') I'm just trying to get Dunwich's lead up.

Dunwich Horror - 10 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 5 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 13 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Same here. I love you Innsmouth, but let's just say this is for Patrice.

Dunwich Horror - 9 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 5

Innsmouth Horror - 9 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Hurt Dunwich because it's out of print and I want it!

Hurt Innsmouth because I had it on order with a huge discount and then then supplier cancelled the order because they were out of stock....

I don't own any of the expansions that are still alive so I am only able to hurt.

Dunwich Horror - 8 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 4 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 13 (heal)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Because Innsmouth, you brought us the Roland Banks and Tommy Muldoon combo of "I'm in charge here!" "...not anymore you're not..."

Oh, and Krawhitham, your math is terrible!

EcnoTheNeato said:

::Laughter:: it was probably a typo, not an assassination attempt ;'D

Dunwich Horror - 7 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 3 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 13 (heal)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

I foresee this game being over tomorrow :')

Dunwich Horror - 6 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 4 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 12 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Nifty Sheldon Gang Memberships are as stupidly rare as Cult Memberships. (Actually, even MORE rare.)
Moon Beasts, Leng Spiders, and Crawling Ones.
Darrell was probably my all-time favorite, and his Personal Story RUINED THAT. For what reason, I have NO IDEA.

morning

Dunwich Horror - 5 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 5 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 11 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Conditions are just nigh impossible to find AND fulfill

Kingsport monsters are some of the best!

Innsmouth is great, but deep one monsters are a slight disappointment

Dunwich Horror - 4 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 6 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 10 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Kingsport board is simply above any others. The rift mechanic is the most original mechanic in the whole AH. Even if others big box expansions are great, Kingsport board is *always* in play for my Arkham games

Julia said:

Dunwich Horror - 6 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 4 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 9 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Dunwich Horror - 5 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 5 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 8 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Dunwich Horror - 4 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 6 (heal)
Innsmouth Horror - 7 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

...unless, somehow, the fact that we can't agree between Dunwich and Kingsport takes out Innsmouth first.

It always bugs me that I have to explain why it's pointless to prepare for a Horror Check against a Wraith.
I love the flavor text of Hypnos' Dream Cards.
The irritation of the Innsmouth Shuffle (monsters moving black, then white, never leaving town).

Dunwich Horror - 5 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 5 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 6 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

I hate to hurt Innsmouth, but Dunwich is better than Kingsport. I hope Innsmouth wins, but I also hope that Dunwich beats out Kingsport.

Dunwich Horror - 6 (heal)
Kingsport Horror - 4 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 5 (hurt)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

Eeengh...it's like some horrible game of chicken. I'm trusting you guys to not deal a finishing blow to Innsmouth here...

Dunwich Horror - 5 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 3 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 6 (heal)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0

For Pete's sake, how did it come to this?!?! I never thought Kingsport could serve as such close competition for Dunwich and Innsmouth!

Solan said:

Well, this board is populated by crazy people after all ;'D

Dunwich Horror - 4 (hurt)
Kingsport Horror - 2 (hurt)
Innsmouth Horror - 7 (heal)

The King in Yellow - 0
Curse of the Dark Pharoah - 0
The Lurker at the Threshold - 0
Black Goat of the Woods - 0