HappyDaze said:
> 2) Almost all of the Deathwatch Black Shield Advances (page 101) appear on the General Space Marine Rank 1 (GSM1) list for equal cost. Is the Black Shield really intended to have so few choices, and if so, why not minimize his list to out all of the redundant skills and talents found on GSM1?
Not all Black Shields start out with access to the General Space Marine ranks... if you feel it is necessary, the GM may (at his discretion) of course add additional options.
I asked myself the same thing when making my character a Black Shield. However - and this may be because I'm totally new to the game - I am not sure I understand the answer.
If the Black Shield is an Advanced speciality meant for Deathwatch space marines, how can they start out without the General Space Marine ranks?
From what I understand, a starting character being Rank 1 can take anything from the Rank 1 General and Deathwatch lists as well as whats available to their Specialty and Chapter. If that is correct, a starting Deathwatch Black Shield loses access to his original Chapter Advances to gain the equivalent of a chapter list with 4 elements on it : Concealment +10 (usually higher rank), Silent Move +10 (usually higher rank), Trade (cheaper), Sound Constitution (x3 for 1000 xp, nice!). These choices are either better priced, not found on the General or Deathwatch Rank 1 lists or not something you automatically get as a Space Marine. Also, compared to the chapter lists that it replaces, it doesn't have a lot of talents available.
"Not all Black Shields start out with access to the General Space Marine ranks"
The only way I could make sense of that is that someone with no prior training as a Space Marine could show up in a blacked out power armor at the Deathwatch and be welcomed as a Brother with no questions asked? Like how someone who can't even hold a bolter quite right found himself a power armor?
Like I said, while I not new to tabletop gaming, this is my first experience with a W40k RPG. So, maybe an ascended character from Dark Heresy can meet the requirement but, then again, the requirement is "Rank 1"; I understand that for everyone but a Space Marine thats starting at 0xp but, Deathwatch starts at 13,000...
So for all us newbies out here, could someone elaborate?
Thanks in advance!