Enemies with both Strength and Craft as Trophies

By commisaro, in Talisman Rules Questions

Hello,

I imagine this has been asked before, but I couldn't find a mention in the previous forums so I apologize if this is a re-post.

What happens when a character defeats one of the enemy cards that has both Strength and Craft (like Cerberus or Lord of the Pits) and wants to trade them in as a trophy? Does the character get BOTH +1 Str and +1 Cra, choose one or the other, or only get the stat they chose to use to defeat the enemy?

Thank you in advance!

Don't apologise. I meant to look this one up ages ago but forgot, so thanks for the reminder :)