Just been reading this,
i see at
situation 1
player "A" rolls a 1, moves reaper to player "b"
player B has to now roll, picks up dice, declares using lucky charm to make the roll 5 or 6
before player b puts dice on table
player A can now cast misfortune to make the roll 1 one, over writing the lucky charm effect.
as the dice has not been rolled or placed down
situation 2
player "A" rolls a 1, moves reaper to player "b"
player B has to now roll, picks up dice,
Player A declares using misfortune to make the roll 1
before player b puts dice on table
player B can now use Lucky Charm to make the die 5/6, over writing the Misfortune.
as the dice has not been rolled or placed down
the dice is then place/rolled on table after all "before the roll" effects have been done
Both wrong!