Each player picks an airplane. Each player then receives a number of M&Ms (or similar small candy) equal to the damage points of the plane selected.

When a player inflicts damage on another player's plane, the firing player takes a number of M&Ms equal to the damage inflicted. (Yes, this does remove the "secret damage" function, but this isn't meant to be taken seriously. )

The winner is the player with the most M&Ms at game's end -- in more ways than one.

Can't do it as the group I play with would eat their M&M's before we could do as you suggest. Great fun though.

Sheppard1972 said:

In that case: Hand out the M&Ms as damage is scored.

(Can't think of a way to handle Critical Hits -- maybe a slightly-larger type of candy, like Hershey's Kisses? )