1. More Guardians, especially ones based off of the Elder Gods.
2. Mordiggian Ancient One.
3. Herald based off the Many-Angled Ones.
4. More boards based of Lovecraft country.
Everyone please pitch in.
Stuff I would like to see
Wolfen Fenrison said:
4. More boards based of Lovecraft country.
What is left that is noteworthy?
Personally I'd like to see New Orleans.
Providence Horror.
No more Guardians. They completely detract from the feel of the game. No more boards. The game is far too cumbersome as it is.
No more boards please!
What we need is an expansion for all expansions! A box containing stuffs that bind all the expansions together like:
- Rift tokens of all the stable locations other than Kingsport (this way, they could change the original rules about rift openning and make it more like the excellent variant proposed by TIBS which rules that the rift open on the last location token drawn).
- New allies, skills, items, spells, and relationship cards (for the items they could add cars as a Ford-T and changed rules about the allies in a way we could use all of them).
- New encounters cards for DH, KH, IH (a good occasion to bind all the boards!)
- A new rules book with all the rules from the previous expansions and including the updated official FAQ. (are you tired of searching!
- Cards, caracters sheets and AO sheets with corrected erratas or updated stats (clarified text about locationareas; Upgraded AO, caracters starting in other towns).
- More tasks and missions cards (cards asking to go to other towns).
- Mythos cards to correct the dilution effect (more next act cards, maybe one the story continue card).
- More monsters tokens (maybe zombies or deep ones to be able to create a scenario; more aquatic)
- Stickers for the unidentified aquatics locations.
- More sanity and stamina tokens (I like to keep them on my caracters sheets for counting their maximum, don't you?).
- Maybe some kind of roulette to keep track of the monsters, outskirt, and gates limits would be cool.
- An official score sheet adapted to the multiboards situation (we need revisited scores rules)
This is only examples of course. I'm sure everyone around here can comes with their own bundle of ideas. Including FFG 
If you wiki lovecraft counties, they have covered all the towns with the big boxes. I think the expansion of adding more to the expansions already out is a great idea. I don't have a problem with guardians.
But wouldn't that be exlusively for people who own ALL expansions? I mean, I own DH and BGotW, and I wouldn't be buying something that includes content I cannot use if I don't have the rest of the expansions. It would be like using such expansion for the expansions at 20% capacity.
Doc Demers said:
No more boards please!
What we need is an expansion for all expansions! A box containing stuffs that bind all the expansions together like:
- Rift tokens of all the stable locations other than Kingsport (this way, they could change the original rules about rift openning and make it more like the excellent variant proposed by TIBS which rules that the rift open on the last location token drawn).
- New allies, skills, items, spells, and relationship cards (for the items they could add cars as a Ford-T and changed rules about the allies in a way we could use all of them).
- New encounters cards for DH, KH, IH (a good occasion to bind all the boards!)
- A new rules book with all the rules from the previous expansions and including the updated official FAQ. (are you tired of searching!
- Cards, caracters sheets and AO sheets with corrected erratas or updated stats (clarified text about locationareas; Upgraded AO, caracters starting in other towns).
- More tasks and missions cards (cards asking to go to other towns).
- Mythos cards to correct the dilution effect (more next act cards, maybe one the story continue card).
- More monsters tokens (maybe zombies or deep ones to be able to create a scenario; more aquatic)
- Stickers for the unidentified aquatics locations.
- More sanity and stamina tokens (I like to keep them on my caracters sheets for counting their maximum, don't you?).
- Maybe some kind of roulette to keep track of the monsters, outskirt, and gates limits would be cool.
- An official score sheet adapted to the multiboards situation (we need revisited scores rules)
This is only examples of course. I'm sure everyone around here can comes with their own bundle of ideas. Including FFG
All great ideas!
5. Heralds for all of Nyralathotep's masks.
6. Rules for interactions between rival monsters (Yithians vs Flying Polyps, Elder Things vs (Proto-)Shoggoths or Star Spawn)
7. Minis for characters and/or monsters.
Wolfen Fenrison said:
5. Heralds for all of Nyralathotep's masks.
6. Rules for interactions between rival monsters (Yithians vs Flying Polyps, Elder Things vs (Proto-)Shoggoths or Star Spawn)
7. Minis for characters and/or monsters.
Oh my God... I would *love* to see a Nyarlathotep focused small box expansion set with multiple heralds. If it was done well.
I second the Crawling Chaos small box.
There are several components that allow for all sort of RPG-light adventures. We have Allies, Corruption cards, Dark Pact cards, Injury/Maddness cards as well as Relationship cards, Membership cards all sorts of stuff that could be put to use. I also think everyone loved League play.
So, I would really dig some sort of Campaign Book. Maybe something with 4 stories in it containing 3 to 5 chapters each. At the end of each chapter the exsisting scoring system could be used (with other objectives) to give the investigators advantages/disadvantages for the begining of the next chapter. Score high- gain allies and more clues, score low- gain Corruption cards. Have heavy contact with the Mythos? Maybe gain benefits but become prone to a Dark Pact (there is an awsome OW card that give the owner increasing power but devours them at the end of so many rounds).
I love all the stuff I have for Arkham Horror and liked that the League play allowed it all to be used.