Blood sucking clarification

By rimmer3, in Talisman Rules Questions

I can't sacrifice bad followers (Hag, Jester, Poltergeist etc.) in the Vampire Tower if I have another followers to leave there.

But I can drain them if I am Vampiress.

Is that correct?

Rimmer said:

I can't sacrifice bad followers (Hag, Jester, Poltergeist etc.) in the Vampire Tower if I have another followers to leave there.

But I can drain them if I am Vampiress.

Is that correct?

Theme-wise, why not? If they are too sticky to leave it doesn't mean you can't kill them if your character is ruthless enough to do so.

But following theme could be not the best way to "interpret" rules. Anyway, I'd say that you can kill them and I'd consider another advantage of being a Vampiress.

Cynewulf said:

Rimmer said:

I can't sacrifice bad followers (Hag, Jester, Poltergeist etc.) in the Vampire Tower if I have another followers to leave there.

But I can drain them if I am Vampiress.

Is that correct?

Theme-wise, why not? If they are too sticky to leave it doesn't mean you can't kill them if your character is ruthless enough to do so.

But following theme could be not the best way to "interpret" rules. Anyway, I'd say that you can kill them and I'd consider another advantage of being a Vampiress.

I think the Vampiress can drain such Followers, just like the Alchemist (Character or Follower) can Alchemise Lodestone and False Grail.

I do not like this ruling since it differs from the "no voluntarily sacrificing bad Followers" rule, but it looks like it has been allowed this way. Hope somebody with more authority than me can confirm or deny.

Rimmer said:

I can't sacrifice bad followers (Hag, Jester, Poltergeist etc.) in the Vampire Tower if I have another followers to leave there.

But I can drain them if I am Vampiress.

Is that correct?

Even if you have only the Hag, jester and poltergeist, you can't choose for those followers in the vampire tower, because you must choose to lose a life.

I think that the Vampire character cannot choose to drain the Hag, jester or poltergeist.

The vampire may drain the life force of her followers, and she can choose which followers she want to discard

Velhart said:

Rimmer said:

I can't sacrifice bad followers (Hag, Jester, Poltergeist etc.) in the Vampire Tower if I have another followers to leave there.

But I can drain them if I am Vampiress.

Is that correct?

Even if you have only the Hag, jester and poltergeist, you can't choose for those followers in the vampire tower, because you must choose to lose a life.

I think that the Vampire character cannot choose to drain the Hag, jester or poltergeist.

The vampire may drain the life force of her followers, and she can choose which followers she want to discard

I've read somewhere that few people play that way: you can discard/consume/sacrifice bad followers only when you haven't any other followers to use. I like this interpretation, but I think we need an official answer about it.

air show said:

Velhart said:

Rimmer said:

I can't sacrifice bad followers (Hag, Jester, Poltergeist etc.) in the Vampire Tower if I have another followers to leave there.

But I can drain them if I am Vampiress.

Is that correct?

Even if you have only the Hag, jester and poltergeist, you can't choose for those followers in the vampire tower, because you must choose to lose a life.

I think that the Vampire character cannot choose to drain the Hag, jester or poltergeist.

The vampire may drain the life force of her followers, and she can choose which followers she want to discard

I've read somewhere that few people play that way: you can discard/consume/sacrifice bad followers only when you haven't any other followers to use. I like this interpretation, but I think we need an official answer about it.

But you can only lose those bad followers if you are forced to discard them. ( and if you have no other followers left) unless you must roll a die for it.

The Vampire gives you a choice to drain your followers. (that is not forcing)