Summer 2020 X-Wing Survey

By Nsara, in X-Wing

If 50% of your respondants are answering a specific way, the last thing you want to do is drop that option. Even if it is a disingenuous response, you want to alter it to remove the motivation for lying (Give it a less cute name), rather than remove the response and create a weird influence on your other choices (ex: If lots of players play 'jank' 90% of the time but goes to aces as a fallback because its the best or they do it at serious tournaments, it may result in aces over-preforming because they are 'the strongest' when most players DON'T play it and want more support for combo or control or whatever).

And I don't think it IS purely disengenous., if you peruse metawing you find some true gems like "Intimidation VCX+Moldy Crow Jan+Wedge, which I think is fair to call jank. Like I guess you could call it an 'aces' list but it clearly doesn't fly at all like an aces list, or a beef list, or whatever. A LOT of archetypes are very strange and there clearly are a large group of people so comfortable with 'jank' that they go to tournaments. Sometimes enough to get a jank list to the top spot for a underused tournament faction like Rebels or Republic! And because these players are likely under-represented at tournaments, it isn't actually hard to believe 50% of the playerbase 100% sincerely plays jank.

But still, I think this comes down to your 'other' choice being poorly worded. I literally thought it meant 'I could not decide between these two options' rather than 'I play something else. You tried to, I think, cover too much ground with one option. If it was more that was the intent of the option (or even better, was split up for a few different reasons like 'A combination of two of these' 'A different archetype' and 'I don't play just one' ect) I think it would be fine.

Also I get this is a fun fan project and your not seriously conducting market research. I am just a borderline parody, because I teach and grade this stuff and it looks like I won't be this year and have nowhere to put this educational energy. I am in full 'will teach for the thrill of one more informative hit' mode!

Also: Yes, write ins are a nightmare and if I recall google doesn't do them very well. Like if I recall correctly you aren't able to create categories to sort write ins so you can collect different variants of the same thing as the same response so you can compare the correlations between different responses, which makes them a total nightmare. No shame in not bothering for a casual survey.

On 8/5/2020 at 11:57 PM, Nsara said:

What’s the green clear majority? It’s not on the legend.

Would be nice if the legend showed in ranked order rather than vice versa. Hard to get much out of that image 😕

17 hours ago, ClassicalMoser said:

What’s the green clear majority? It’s not on the legend.

Would be nice if the legend showed in ranked order rather than vice versa. Hard to get much out of that image 😕

it would be nice if the responses preview wasn't a total piece of garbage, but it isn't. This is why it's gonna take me a week or two to go through all the data

Give you two guesses what the majority leader is. It rhymes with "Hondo Best"

Heres a breakdown of most wanted ships back when I was at 844 responses (up to 896 now), not pulling more recent data until the survey closes.

  1. Razorcrest - 23.6% 1st choice, 15.6% 2nd choice
  2. ETA-2 Actis - 14.4% 1st choice, 6.6% 2nd choice
  3. TIE/rb Brute - 7.2% 1st choice, 7.2% 2ND
  4. Droid Tri-Fighter - 6.1% 1st, 6.9% 2nd
  5. First Order Bomber - 5.9% 1st, 5.3% 2nd
  6. The Ark Angel - 5.1% 1st, 5.8% 2nd Resistance
  7. B-Wing - 4.4% 1st, 3.2% 2nd
  8. T-85 X-Wing - 4.3% 1st, 5.7% 2nd