The One Ring

By Sincereagape, in Star Wars: Edge of the Empire RPG

Okay, I really didn't mean to go on such a long rant, because that wasn't actually the point. The real trouble is that The One Ring is difficult to tinker with, and with such a prominent problem, it wasn't something I was willing to deal with. Backing up that issue was the attitude of the folks on the Cubicle 7 forums. It was basically, "you're wrong, this isn't a problem." I ran into the same thing constantly with AEG's version of L5R.

If a game can't handle tinkering, I don't want it. I'm not a big fan of D&D 5e, but I enjoy banging away at the engine, because it can handle it. Star Wars and Genesys are pretty solid as written, but the community is supportive when people want to tweak things. Usually. Seven years of "What if I used X-Wing Miniatures rules for space combat in the RPG?!" elicits a lot of groans at this point, but folks are still civil about it and have good advice to offer.

I've come up with a lot of bonehead ideas, and I'm usually met with, "I think you're going down the wrong path, but if you wanna try it you might do this and this..." Then a few days later I come back with my pants ripped, my elbows skinned, covered in mud, saying, "Yeah, you were right. That was the wrong path."

On 5/1/2020 at 10:44 PM, P-47 Thunderbolt said:

The One Force-Ring

Haha. Is this what Snoke was using (the ring with that big black stone on it)? He did seem to be really quite powerful. Even more powerful than the Emperor was in previous movies... but then, turns out he WAS the Emperor! hahaha. Fooled you all! Or something.

Ah! Perhaps Snoke was like one of the 9 Riders! That's why there had been other one's as well... and that Ring was what kept him in Sauron, ahem, I mean Palpatine's thrall! This stuff writes itself!

8 hours ago, dreenan said:

yes, but most probable not axes and poleaxes

Well, it is.

in short:

Axes are not that different. and most people have picked them up. If you can chop wood you can chop people. there are things you are more likely to screw up so you might get a little bit of a set back but you shouldnt be made to be completely unskilled. that is just silly. especially if you are a warrior.

Edited by Daeglan
Quote

If you can chop wood you can chop people.

Just switch brick for wood

*oh please let this thread devolve like the recent one about armor!*