Is Heroic Better Than A Bid?

By Boom Owl, in X-Wing

This is waay too context specific for a blanket answer.

13 minutes ago, Flurpy said:

This is waay too context specific for a blanket answer.

Yes. But on the other hand: I do not remember a single squad where I removed Heroic for a bid.

It is very likely that always adding heroic is not the best choice, and yet I do. 5A without heroics would have a nice bid for mirrors and other i5s. But I would never remove it. There is even a version with Zizi Tallie Greer 2x Blues with just 4 heroics, and I suspect that it might be the best current version, even if lacking Ronith. But that one missing heroic is a huge, irrational disincentive.

Cova Kaz Jess Bastian? Heroic. Poe XXX? Heroic. Rey Cova Kaz? No heroic, but also no bid.

Generally yes outside trying to hit specific bid threshold, but I have to ask, "So what?" Bidding is an unpleasant metagame activity, and it shouldn't be used as a benchmark for design decisions.

I don’t always fly Resistance, but when I do every ship that can take heroic has it.

I take Heroic on almost any ship that will be rolling just 2 dice at some point. What do you need a bid for anyway? Go for the 'ol block and kill box.

Tali - Turns out the bid helps Tali I guess? Something something bullseye
OOuxrud.png
sMZim1V.png

Zizi - Turns out the Bid doesnt matter much for Zizi I guess? Something something yolo token stacking boosty all blue moves turret
m6V4Lm3.png
sBdZdwV.png