Things are bad cuz they're currently costed bad/willy-nilly - A depressing thought

By Blail Blerg, in X-Wing

10 minutes ago, KettchGER said:

Autoblaster-M3As are ridiculously undercosted right now. 7 of them is like a >240 pointish list.

Not the only spam list that looks good.

What about 7x Concussion Z-95s? 6x double-modded Hyena Protorps? 5xI5 Torrent Mag-Pulse?

Problem is they have only one trick, they bleed MoV super fast, and they all have significant weaknesses (for the Scyk it's their subpar speed/maneuverability).

Good? Maybe. Worth 240 points? Not by a long shot.

I may be wrong. I'd love to see how they perform in the near future.

3 minutes ago, ClassicalMoser said:

Not the only spam list that looks good.

What about 7x Concussion Z-95s? 6x double-modded Hyena Protorps? 5xI5 Torrent Mag-Pulse?

Problem is they have only one trick, they bleed MoV super fast, and they all have significant weaknesses (for the Scyk it's their subpar speed/maneuverability).

Good? Maybe. Worth 240 points? Not by a long shot.

I may be wrong. I'd love to see how they perform in the near future.

Don't forget Rebel or Republic Y-ons+Proton Bombs

oh lets not forget that 5 RZ1 A-wings with prockets and crackshot fits, and that is something immensely fun to play!

1 minute ago, Wiredin said:

oh lets not forget that 5 RZ1 A-wings with prockets and crackshot fits, and that is something immensely fun to play!

Though you can't Crack a Procket.

You can Marksmanship it though, which is just as fun.

Unpopular opinion: Intimidation is the better talent and is hyperspace legal. Phoenix with Intimidation and Concussions is low key the best A-Wing and better than RZ-2s fight me.

Saw this on ListFortress from the Sith Takers Hyperspace event. It looks really interesting to me:

Cartel Spacer (25)
Tractor Beam (3)

Cartel Spacer (25)
Tractor Beam (3)

Cartel Spacer (25)
Ion Cannon (6)

Cartel Spacer (25)
Ion Cannon (6)

Zealous Recruit (41)

Zealous Recruit (41)
Total: 200

View in Yet Another Squad Builder 2.0

1 hour ago, KettchGER said:

Autoblaster-M3As are ridiculously undercosted right now. 7 of them is like a >240 pointish list.

Have you flown this? I mean, really? Having flown a Scyk swarm with autoblasters, I don't believe in it. Yes, those crits from out of arc are wonderful, but since most of the time you only have a focus token you don't exactly get much reliability on getting them. It's a great weapon on the Scyk, I definitely recommend, but it's not exactly a reliable list.

1 hour ago, ClassicalMoser said:

Though you can't Crack a Procket.

You can Marksmanship it though, which is just as fun.

Unpopular opinion: Intimidation is the better talent and is hyperspace legal. Phoenix with Intimidation and Concussions is low key the best A-Wing and better than RZ-2s fight me.

true you can't crack a procket. but crack is great for late game clean up!

I really wish we would have gotten an i5 or i6 RZ-1 pilot in the aces pack...... Hera in an RZ-1 is a dream! I would also take Sabine, even at i3 in an A-wing. it's not broken I swear.

Edited by Wiredin
39 minutes ago, LagJanson said:

Have you flown this? I mean, really? Having flown a Scyk swarm with autoblasters, I don't believe in it. Yes, those crits from out of arc are wonderful, but since most of the time you only have a focus token you don't exactly get much reliability on getting them. It's a great weapon on the Scyk, I definitely recommend, but it's not exactly a reliable list.

The main point for equipping the autoblaster is the extra-attack die in bullseye-arc.

You basically get this package for just 28 points (with only Ini 1 though):

New Squadron

(31) "Scourge" Skutu [TIE/ln Fighter]
(8) Shield Upgrade
Points: 39

Total points: 39

@Blail Blerg Extended is fine. Most of the top lists at LVO were basically same lists pre-points updates. Some lists like FOcho, and Kylo + 4 popped up, and maybe Fenn got a couple upgraded friends, but many dominant extended lists stayed at the top.

Hyperspace is where things are gonna get a little crazy because aces and pre-move actions/shenanigans is all but gone. Gonna just be jousty joust-wing. Ace + miniswarm is the only hope ace players have in hyperspace. But every faction should be well represented in hyperspace. Nothing really stands out as OP, and without any major hyperspace tournies to draw from, its just too early to really tell.

Edited by wurms

I'm talking about at the edge of terrible and Tier3 garbage. Some pilots are so terrible they're actually a time wasting trap.

Not about meta diversity at a tournament or the health of formats. Surprise, if those pilots are in that hype format with all of its own meta issues, they're still the same cost even if its mitigated slightly by a reduction of tier1 stuff.

2 hours ago, gamblertuba said:

Saw this on ListFortress from the Sith Takers Hyperspace event. It looks really interesting to me:

Cartel Spacer (25)
Tractor Beam (3)

Cartel Spacer (25)
Tractor Beam (3)

Cartel Spacer (25)
Ion Cannon (6)

Cartel Spacer (25)
Ion Cannon (6)

Zealous Recruit (41)

Zealous Recruit (41)
Total: 200

View in Yet Another Squad Builder 2.0

Yeah Si picked that up from me. It’s very very good, and I know a bunch of us are taking it to the System Open.

I’ve lost one game with it where I got the engage hilariously wrong. Before that defeat I’d lost <1 ship per game on average.

1 hour ago, Blail Blerg said:

I'm talking about at the edge of terrible and Tier3 garbage. Some pilots are so terrible they're actually a time wasting trap.

Not about meta diversity at a tournament or the health of formats. Surprise, if those pilots are in that hype format with all of its own meta issues, they're still the same cost even if its mitigated slightly by a reduction of tier1 stuff.

Care to elaborate or specifics here? I personally have either personally used or seen all the Empires and First Orders ships hit the table and been competitive. Doesn’t mean they are world breaking monsters but can be flown well enough to make a competitive game without just being rolled over like a penny on a railroad track.

1 hour ago, KettchGER said:

The main point for equipping the autoblaster is the extra-attack die in bullseye-arc.

You basically get this package for just 28 points (with only Ini 1 though):

New Squadron

(31) "Scourge" Skutu [TIE/ln Fighter]
(8) Shield Upgrade
Points: 39

Total points: 39

*shrug* You’re welcome to go buy a swarm of the guys and try to run up scores in Hyperspace then. From experience, I wouldn’t. They are a great deal, but you’re going to be disappointed with how the theory plays out in practice if you think seven are going to be lining up bullseye shots all the time. With four I normally got one a game (sometimes more with large base)

12 hours ago, GreenDragoon said:

Don't try to make the game bad for others because you don't enjoy it right now.

isnt that your whole thing?

2 hours ago, Blail Blerg said:

I'm talking about at the edge of terrible and Tier3 garbage.

Care to elaborate?

2 hours ago, Blail Blerg said:

Some pilots are so terrible they're actually a time wasting trap.

No, they're not. They've almost all been used seriously at competitive events, and the ones that haven't probably will be soon due to the huge buffs they recently received (VCX, YT-2400, Generics, etc).

The only ones I can think of are named Defenders and E-Wings, but even they have seen at least some competitive success, and they have more room for friends and toys now.

Bringing up Hyperspace as a solution to pilots being unplayable is pretty laughable. The entire concept of the format is that a lot of stuff isn’t playable. Wedge currently isn’t playable in Hyperspace, for goodness sake!

On 2/3/2020 at 2:50 PM, Blail Blerg said:

I'm talking about at the edge of terrible and Tier3 garbage. Some pilots are so terrible they're actually a time wasting trap.

On 2/3/2020 at 5:45 PM, ClassicalMoser said:

No, they're not. They've almost all been used seriously at competitive events,

Let's also not forget that this game is far more than tounaments.

There's Epic, there's kitchen table, and there's *gasp* just playing with the crappiest stuff just to see how far you can get before you crash and burn.

There are folks who think the junk is fun jank. There are folks who play just cuz Star Wars. Let them have their less than perfect toys.*

*And no, I WON'T enjoy the game more when it's perfect, despite that being the usual counter claim for why we should all want it perfect.

Edited by Darth Meanie
1 hour ago, Darth Meanie said:

There are folks who play just cuz Star Wars. Let them have their less than perfect toys.*

I always think this when people talk about ships that might come out but probably won't because something like it already fills that role.

Just because the Lambda exists in the game doesn't mean I don't want Krennic's shuttle.

I don't always want new ships because of new mechanics, sometimes I want new ships just to have different ships to play Star Wars with.

On 2/3/2020 at 3:50 PM, Blail Blerg said:

I'm talking about at the edge of terrible and Tier3 garbage. Some pilots are so terrible they're actually a time wasting trap.

Not about meta diversity at a tournament or the health of formats. Surprise, if those pilots are in that hype format with all of its own meta issues, they're still the same cost even if its mitigated slightly by a reduction of tier1 stuff.

I legitimately have no idea what you're saying here? I can't even parse your sentences here.

Are you complaining there are bad pilots? There have always been bad pilots. I'm sorry if they're your favorites this time.

If I'm reading this right (and as I try to read this I feel like I might be having a stroke so I'm not sure) you don't care about healthy formats or meta diversity, which are both in great shape, by the way. So what exactly is is behind your proclamation that everything is trash and X-Wing is the worst ever now?

2 hours ago, Dr Moneypants said:

Are you complaining there are bad pilots? There have always been bad pilots. I'm sorry if they're your favorites this time.

I'm leaning toward the "my favorite list from the past 6 months doesn't fit anymore". So he is complaining.